Search:

brb got some Judges to fight

I totally agree, I'd did not expect the answers I got, but they were consistent.
If I cast Portent and my opponent shuffled the top three before handing them over, that's an immediate judge call...

Just got back from the SCG event at Valley Forge PA.
Got feedback from a number of judges presented with this scenario.

A few said they could not make a final determination without looking a the...

I'd think the order would be revealed, yeah. See top card first, second card second, etc.
But is that explicitly part of the rules or just the "spirit of the game" type of stuff, because that's...

If I cast Portent and target my opponent, is the order of the three cards intrinsic to the looking at the three cards when resolving the spell?
If in paper, upon resolution of Portent, my opponent...