Search:

Weird. I saw the discussion and I'm glad no one is calling for the illegality of a card that Scryfall says is legacy/vintage/commander playable. When I saw BMC a few weeks ago, I actually wondered...

Me: 7. silkster: Ebon Stronghold, Vault of the Archangel, Agonizing Remorse, Black Market Connections

1. Asthereal (TO): Azorius Chancery, Faerie Conclave, Energy Field, Detention Sphere LL
I...

Rooster doesn't have enough mana to play Words of Wilding, then play EE for 2 (cause it has to be 2 different colours) and then crack EE. So you just don't play Energy Field until Rooster has cast...

As far as I can tell, three disagreements remain:

Reeplcheep vs RoosterCocoa: I think this is WD for RoosterCocoa. Keeping Peat Bog to play turn 2 EE on 1, then blow up one or both enchantments...

Me: 4. silkster: Cave of the Frost Dragon, Fountain of Cho, March of Otherworldly Light, Feldon's Cane

1. Asthereal (TO): Razortide Bridge, Razortide Bridge, Energy Field, Luminarch Ascension...

When I saw that I was losing to your deck, I wondered if I had just chosen the worse version of discard. After Gut Shot + Drill Bit did well enough, I hoped this would too, though I know that a...

Ah, I saw scores of DD and DL, and I could see that alphastryk didn't lose, but forgot to check whether alphastryk actually wins instead. This look right to me. WD for alphastryk.

FTW has DD, and I think that's right. Raze forces out the counter, and then the two 1/1s trade with Path and Recruit. If FTW doesn't expose the land to Raze, you just make the two 1/1s instead.

Me: silkster: Blackcleave Cliffs, Strike It Rich, Devour Intellect, Okiba Reckoner Raid

1. Asthereal (TO): Rustvale Bridge, Angel's Grace, Pact of the Titan, Pact of the Titan
I wondered if you...

One disagreement, which is me arguing I do worse than my opponent thought. :(

Me: 9. silkster: Saprazzan Skerry, Seat of the Synod, Rise and Shine, Stubborn Denial

1. Asthereal (TO): Plains,...

Yeah, I thought it looked good at a glanceI was actually just looking at an Offer You Can't Refuse + Sprout based deck and noticing that it would have gotten about 4 round points a few rounds ago,...

That was me. The other disagreement was something that I got wrong the first time too. I think once dte sees either RoosterCocoa's post or mine, it will be settled.

In any case, it looks like a...

8. silkster: Badlands, Chrome Mox, Kuldotha Rebirth, Mind Swords - Round: Goblins Smash!

1. Asthereal (TO): Plains, Angel's Grace, Pact of the Titan, Pact of the Titan WW
2. GoblinSmashmaster:...

In my mind, Reality Acid combo and Barren Glory were similar in power and resilience but Reality Acid crushes Barren Glory, so I figured that if anyone played either it would be Reality Acid.

The...

I'm good to organize a season or two. For a moment I was going to say that I'd only do a specific type of season, but then I realized that I'd have the power to choose at that point anyway! Now that...

This was actually my original proposal (or decks scoring strictly greater than 3), but I'm actually really happy with the evolution from round to round. While planning my R8 deck, I did a quick check...

10. silkster: Tomb of Urami, Molten Slagheap, Gut Shot, Drill Bit

1. Asthereal (TO): Mana Vault, Karn, Scion of Urza, Manifold Key, Dust Bowl WL
2. dte: Swamp, Encroach, tel-jilad stylus,...

I had this many lists that I was looking at, the only overlap with the banlist is that Lush Growth/Mental Misstep slot. I guess I don't need to brew now, only decide about what I have, which is...

Me. silkster: Hickory Woodlot, Island, Rhonas's Last Stand, Stubborn Denial

1. Asthereal (TO): Golgari Rot Farm, Treetop Village, Assassin's Trophy, Mental Misstep
Damn! I thought Assassin's...

I hadn't done the math and was just making a minimum list, but on inspection it looks pretty straightforward. Seven others said they went WL and I trust those, then Sea's Claim beats the Peat Bog and...

I don't know what you're pairing with Metrognome (and you can save your tech), but my Metrognome decks would have done quite badly this round. I think too many of them allowed my opponents to just...

I spent a long time trying to play around the T1 discard decks, so I worried that playing Hymn or the like would run into something like Misdirection. I didn't have a 2-mana 5/5 in my list though, so...

ROUND 6: The T1 Round

Me: 9. silkster: Blinkmoth Nexus, Mox Sapphire, Mox Ruby, Wheel of Fortune

1. Asthereal (TO): Blinkmoth Mexus, Mox Sapphire, Sea's Claim, Thorn of Amethyst WL
2....

Me: 9. silkster: Hall of Storm Giants, Calciform Pools, Disrupting Shoal, Pact of Negation

1. Asthereal (TO): Island, Mana Crypt, Wistful Thinking, Donate WW
2. dte: Channel, Mox emerald, Karn...

I was the one who put in most of the scores for people who had already done writeups, then I noticed that mismatch and pointed it out at the bottom of my own post. GoblinSmashmaster must have seen it...