Search:

They're small tuning things that wouldn't show up goldfishing but would affect how the deck plays against Tier 1 decks. Overall the deck idea looks good. Good luck!

Interesting deck!

If you prefer UG to UW, a few things:
1) 3 Run Afoul or Pick Your Poison in the SB help with scary flyers (Marit Lage, Archon of Cruelty, Emrakul, Murktide). Otherwise UG...

The Malcolm deck is atypical. It's a brew from a small weekly event of 13 players. See the other decks linked above. The other builds are doing better.

The most successful build now is Bant (UWG)....

Thrull does a lot of useful stuff in non-Goldfish games, because it disrupts the opponent at instant speed. Because it's a removal target, an extra copy is not a bad thing.

4 Thrull has been the...

Is it having any success in paper Stoneforge builds?

The 1 putting up results (Coat) I made a note saying was good, just that it doesn't work with Thrull. Both Thrull & Coat builds have 4xStP, because removal matters like I said.

Guess Costume isn't...

4th place MTGO Legacy Challenge Bant Stiflenought:
https://www.mtgtop8.com/event?e=52576&d=590274&f=LE

4x Doorkeeper Thrull

Also
0x Hide in Plain Sight
0x Eater of Days
0x Worldly Tutor
0x...

Looks good. Nice results. I'm a big fan of the UW version.

Could those Tameshis just be Murktides? 3 Murktide seems good if you're not on Uro. Or Curie.

The 1-of Masterwork makes sense if...

Curie still seems better because
- it's a proactive turn 2 play that forces opponent to leave a blocker or hold removal
- it works standalone as an Ophidian, doesn't need combo pieces to be...

Unless they're changing the rules it would seem to. Older cards like Lazav, the Multifarious say the copy retains the Legendary supertype.

So you could have one Curie out and one Curie-Nought,...

Can exile Dreadnought in response to sacrifice trigger (from cast or Saga), seems good.

Still seems good to protect with Legolas vs Costume. Or Fow/Daze.

The shroud only lasts one turn, doesn't move, costs 2 mana, and doesn't have Split Second (can be responded to).

"What if they had bigger creatures" than vanilla 2/2s (what the Cloak is most of...

Seems worse than Legolas's Quick Reflexes for a creature that already has trample.

That looks even better cutting green and just running Murktide as a finisher instead of Uro. More stable mana. Daze + Wasteland mana denial plan makes more sense with many threats on 2 mana.

The Bant version looks good. Thrull has been performing well online.

What's your list? I'm surprised they didn't post it if it was that different.

I don't like Hide. I like Coat but think its suboptimal in Dreadnought without a good interactive plan. I'm also open...

Oddly the same day (02-10) they posted 3 Turbo Goblins, including 2 identical lists from the same pilot.

The 2 Stiflenought lists posted (02-10) both look different from what 4Dogs was talking...

They have all the Legacy League 5-0 dumps up to Saturday, Saturday Challenge results, and Friday Prelim results. See same link above.

Friday had 2 Stiflenought 5-0s:
1 UW with 4x Doorkeeper...

Missed that post earlier. Did you edit to add the list?

OK this looks a lot more viable than the UG Hide in Plain Sight + Worldly Tutor + Eater of Days stuff earlier.

White removal for bigger...

https://www.mtggoldfish.com/tournaments/legacy#paper

This week's results are up. 1 Cryptic Cloak in Cephalid Breakfast, but don't see any Cloak-Nought yet.

If you do get good results, looking...

Both that and the FoW/Daze arguments are ridiculous exaggerations. The point is you need adequate compensation for spending more mana than a cheaper effect.

Cancel is invalidated by Counterspell;...

No one plays Cancel when other cards do the same for less mana, so mana cost matters. Why not play a 7-mana enabler?

HiPS costs 4 (+ 1 to tutor) to make a Dreadnought that dies to the same things...

I meant 3 per turn (over 2 turns). As in they don't waste 2 FULL turns like you claimed. On both turns they have other mana left & permanents played from turns 1-2, while the UG deck played no early...

Not 2 full turns. If you spent 4 mana (+1 on tutor too?), they answer for 3, they can do other things. If your deck made no threats turn 1-2 and theirs did, they're already ahead.

The 12/12 is a...

Hide in Plain Sight, they can just remove over 2 turns: 3 per turn. 2/2 is slow. They have time & mana left to do other things. If you flip, it loses Ward.

Making 2 2/2s for 3G is not impressive,...