@Replenish Discussion: Three Replenish in general is probably too much. They become weaker as you run more, regardless of cycling Confinements and such. And against board sweeps, I'd rather have real answers and stuff that lets me combo off rather than more chance to get stuck on lands/sorceries. I really can't imagine boarding them in, tbh.

@City of Solitude Discussion: Or City of Solitude, especially against Goblins. Yuck. You're boarding in cards to stop 4 of their cards?

The odds that they even get a Port are less than 50%. So half the time, City of Solitude is equivalent to boarding in Choke against Goblins (which, by the way, I think is a better card than City of Solitude because it does the same thing that CoS does: Demand a counterspell or immediate removal. Except Choke makes itself harder to remove and it hurts players who didn't counter it instead of sitting there dead).

Unless you have some SERIOUSLY dead cards or something, City of Solitude is probably not an improvement in the Goblins MU and is pretty much strictly worse than Choke for everything else.


Looks pretty standard. I always try to have 4x Ground Seal (not just against annoying Loam decks, but the Night's Whisper really helps keeping an early Confinement on the table).

I think that Mirri's Guile is superior to Sylvan Library for most metas. I typically have one extra mana a lot more often than I have two extra mana and they have similar functions. Library doesn't work with Solitary, unfortunately. But both benefit from having a lot of shuffle functions. You're only running 4 Heaths, so I don't think either would be very strong in your deck.

Cut it for Hoofprints of the Stag? I'm starting to really like that card. It sticks four power on the table for 3 mana and can also put a 4/4 on the table in the midgame. It combos pretty well with Elephant Grass to buy you the time you need to start churning tokens out.

I'd really consider cutting some Wild Growths and/or Utopia Sprawls for Chrome Moxen. It's a pretty big jump, but Chrome Moxen really help.