I take statistics so I know how difficult this would be to accomplish but it would be interesting to see a breakdown of the reasons for why people like/dislike Goyf in addition to the way that they voted. Also, I personally think that part of the reason that so many deckbuilders dislike or supposedly dislike Goyf is because of the decks they build.

It's common knowledge that most decks people build fail when run through a testing gauntlet if compared to other top tier decks but why? The real reason is probably that the concept did not work or the deck doesn't fit into the metagame in a way it was intended to, but most people would not want to say that about their own deck. I personally hate to admit I'm wrong, and if I could or can use Tarmogoyf as a scapegoat for my failure and say that Tarmogoyf rather than my underpowered deck was the reason I failed then I would/will do that. Just my opinion, but I think it makes a lot of sense that people don't like Tarmogoyf because it brings up the overall power level of Legacy above where their creation would be able to compete.