Quote Originally Posted by nodahero View Post
Actually it does not prove that in the least.

For simplicity sake let us imagine a meta game of 15 decks composed of all islands and this deck... clearly it will win... Yes I understand I am over simplifying it but the point is it really does not prove a single thing.
Over simplifying? No, much worse. Your point is if it was a decent deck playing in a meta of a bunch of bad decks it will win but did you even take a look at the results before saying that? That tournament had 174 players and take a look at the top 8:

http://www.mtgthesource.com/forums/s...mpionship-Top8

That deck has proven itself already in that tournament and nothing will change that.