- pretty much dead against all kinds of combo-matchups (-)
- against fair decks:
Very strong if they cannot interrupt her (+), however there are several cards that, in fact, are able to do so (-):
• Red: Lightning Bolt, Punishing Fires (Jund, Thresh)
• Vendilion Clique (Esper, Miracle)
• Lingering Souls (Esper)
- if they can infere with her Elspeth ends up soaking up a chunk of damage, which as a worst case scenario is pretty good (+)

Elspeth on a scale 1-6 (1 = best)
against
1. Jund: 3+ or 2-
2. Esperblade: 2-
3. Thresh: 3
4. U/W Miracle: 2+
5. all kinds of combo (TES, S&T, Reanimator, Elves): 6 or 5

So yeah, rather mediocre? What do you think?