Quote Originally Posted by Acclimation View Post
@cogitoergosum

The problem I have with Burnt Offering is that it requires a creature on the field. Children does nothing to fuel this, and while Griselbrand will give us all of the mana, I feel that the card will be dead more often than not.

Cabal Ritual isn't a bad one, but the 2 cmc cost is rough.

I've always felt that my bottleneck mid combo was not drawing a Petal type effect to continue, and Cabal Ritual isn't easily cast in that situation.

I think a Snapcaster Mage build could get away with a singleton Culling the Weak though. Not sure what the most optimal build would be for that though.

Richard Cheese and I tested Burnt Offering in some of the original iterations of the deck - it was ALMOST good enough, but as you mentioned, only good post combo phase. Similar but less pronounced with Cabal Ritual. We need cards that are good before and after - that's why LDV works so well. I didn't like either of them for those reasons, at any rate.