[Archetype] Doran Rock (Deed-less Rock)

[Captain Hammer]

Legacy gives you Deed. Legacy gives you Survival.

Legacy gives you Pyroclasm. How many goblin decks do you see playing Pyroclasm?

Just because Legacy gives you a card doesn't mean you should play it. You have to consider if the card actually fits the decks game plan.

As for your other questions. Just read the OP! Every single question you ask about, I already answered there.

--------------------------------------------

Inspite of top 4ing this past month out of 156 people in a meta filled with decks like threshold, dreadstill, fairie stompy and merfolk, absolutely no one here seems even remotely interested in discussing anything similar to the list.

http://www.deckcheck.net/deck.php?id=23005

In spite of it being made clear that this is an early game aggro deck that aims to win by turn 7 all while disrupting your opponent and removed their threats, unlike The Rock or Survival which are designed for the midgame, people prefer to talk about their own midgame decks lists of Survival and The Rock inspite of already having their own threads for doing so.

I'm requesting the mods to close the thread.

I or another poster will keep you posted on any other other top 8s the deck achieves in large tournaments (100+ participants) over in the tournament thread.

And the OP will still be available for the players that want to learn more about the deck. And legacy players that actually are interested in Doran Rock are free to PM me to share more information.

But for all The Rock, Survival and the It's the Fear players. You'll have to go back to your own threads to discuss your decks. I know those threads have not been very active recently. But that's not on me.

[Rood]

Such a heated argument over 2 cards makes no sense. Deed and Survival are going to be brought up if you make a Rock thread Hammer it's unavoidable you mind as well just bother not replying then getting worked up over it. GWB Doran Survival is similiar to this deck in alot of ways so it's not really that big a deal if people bring it up. Deed is the never-ending force card Rock has been created on since the beginning of time so you have to expect people to throw that card out there, whether it be right or wrong. While you can disagree that those cards don't belong in this deck I think you should have a more open mind about discussing them.

[scrow213]

Legacy gives you Pyroclasm. How many goblin decks do you see playing Pyroclasm?

Just because Legacy gives you a card doesn't mean you should play it. You have to consider if the card actually fits the decks game plan.

I already explained detail in the OP why Deed hurts the deck more than it helps it. If you want to play 3 copies of Deed in the deck. Fine, go ahead. But imho, you're making a mistake.

If Deed is such a must play here. Why isn't it played in Eva Green?

If you tried the list, you would realize just how remarkably similar to Eva Green this deck plays out.

Sure a builds of Eva Green play Deed. But they shouldn't. For the same reasons why they shouldn't play it in Doran Rock. The same reasons I enumeratd several times here.

I think he made a very good point about why you should run Deed. Pyroclasm isn't run because it doesn't shore up trouble matches.

[Bardo]

Closed upon request of poster who started this thread.