I believe they were probably thrown out and probably taken by an employee. I guess trash is stolen property but at that point it's looking to be disposed, so is it really stealing? I was comparing it to the Slivers because iirc those were actually intended to be released and stolen or printed without permission.
I know where he got them from. They're legit, and I have to leave it at that. I have a number of CoTs and SotFs too (coincidentally, I own his CoT designs as well), and those were obtained legitimately too.
Test prints aren't obtained through dumpster diving. Cards like the double backed mana flare I posted above, yeah, that's essentially stuff that was meant to be disposed of. Stuff like the CoTs and the later test prints were given out legitimately to employees and made their way out from there. Stuff like the textless saga stuff was in product. Some is illegitimately leaked out, obviously, but that's occured only for the earlier test prints up to Destiny and a bit of Judgment. You're thinking of summer when you speak of dumpster diving. Stolen stuff like the Slivers are a markedly different case whereby the only way they could have make it into the public is by theft. The rest of the stuff has typically made it out the same way Garfield celebration cards have made it into the possession of collectors like me -- through purchases from people who were originally given them. Legitimately.
The CoTs are 100% legal for play, as are textless Karns.
One must imagine Sisyphus happy.
"I'm willing to imagine a TES where Past in Flames replaces Ill-Gotten Gains entirely, and we just don't play Diminishing Returns." - me, 29/09/2011
Founding member of Team Scrubbad: Legacy Legends
It doesn't have any text, just like the Bolt iirc.
-Matt
My Christmas present to myself came today: it was a Beta Savannah! Hooray!
-Matt
The silver-bordered foil test prints are not tournament-legal due to their borders, but the BB ones are. The foil test prints that I once owned were given out to playtesters to test a new foiling process to see how it wore. They played them unsleeved and the edges wore down a bit but the fronts stayed nice and shiny.
Some info on test prints here
http://www.magiclibrarities.net/719-...rds-index.html
and here are pics
karns + others
http://www.magiclibrarities.net/719-...rds-other.html
cities
http://www.magiclibrarities.net/718-...k--border.html
karns don't have names.
The Island ritual is one of the Holy Grails in that list, for sure. Afaik, even a few people on here haven't even seen one, and I'm pretty sure the only picture of one is THAT particular one.
Occam, do you even have one of the Ritual/Islands?
-Matt
My foil loot for the day (I paid less than stickers say):
![]()
Nice, Guilded Lotus and Pattern are tricky to pick up without paying a ton as a foil.
Shrug, I can't imagine it would be that serious an issue considering the pic is there. I mean, I can't read the names on non-English cards that my opponents play, but they're still legal. It really depends on your judge and your opponents. I have never had issues in Vintage, and I've played some pretty crazy stuff. EDH, though, I play stuff in there that's not fair at all. I play split cards in EDH that don't exist.
There are currently 4 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 4 guests)