Quote Originally Posted by Magik321 View Post
MTG Fanatic is one of the more crappy stores I've seen around. Besides the crappy customer service, and rumors that they swapped NM cards for EX ones (then returning you) when you try to sell them cards, they didnt even ship out my order for 1 month. No replies nothing. After many emails later, they just said to me they didnt want to do business with me. Their president is a total ass.

Regarding the rumors I was hearing. I once sent a package of NM/NM+/pack fresh cards to them (I double checked all my cards properly and my grading is fairly strict). The cards that they rejected for not being NM, came back to me with heavy whitening on the edges. The cards rejected were secured very well, no way they could ever been damaged in the mail. Some of the cards I sent them were just opened from boosters. I doubt that was a coincidence that all the cards rejected, went to them NMish and came back damaged.

Tons of f'ed up stores around anyway.
I've had similar issues. Honestly, I think their site is fucking garbage, but it does also happen that they buy some really dumb shit in their buy list, so
I do take advantage of that. They are very quick to "reject" and then "take cards to cover the cost of shipping," which is annoying. And yes, the president is a complete imbecile. Btw, has anyone sold to them recently? I haven't seen payment in almost a month.