Quote Originally Posted by Mockingbird View Post
According the latest update to the missed triggered ruling I could find (I checked this time to make sure this time), your logic cannot hold true given how fast the errors were caught with Chalice of the Void. If I am mistaken, please feel free to point the Wizards statement that would make the following false.

"Now, your responsibilities as the opponent are the same across different types of tournaments. If a triggered ability is forgotten (or any other game error is made) and the error is discovered later, players should alert the judge. The judge will try and fix the error if possible and, if not, the game will just continue."

Source

The judge was right, you didn't resolve your spells fast enough, but not in terms of physical movement, but in terms of making the game state irreparable to "unresolve" them. The only way your logic would hold is if Chalice of the Void was a may ability.
You mean like this one, from the link you just posted, and is the standing rules on how to handle missed triggers?: "Your opponent gets to decide whether he or she wants the trigger to happen or not." -- If you miss a triggered ability and it's caught later, your opponent simply gets to choose. In Jeremiah's case, the judge was blatantly retarded and should have immediately asked if Jeremiah wanted the spell to resolve--to which Jeremiah would obviously want it to do so.