Page 6 of 9 FirstFirst ... 23456789 LastLast
Results 101 to 120 of 165

Thread: Cheating or clever use of the rules?

  1. #101

    Re: Cheating or clever use of the rules?

    Quote Originally Posted by Mockingbird View Post
    According the latest update to the missed triggered ruling I could find (I checked this time to make sure this time), your logic cannot hold true given how fast the errors were caught with Chalice of the Void. If I am mistaken, please feel free to point the Wizards statement that would make the following false.

    "Now, your responsibilities as the opponent are the same across different types of tournaments. If a triggered ability is forgotten (or any other game error is made) and the error is discovered later, players should alert the judge. The judge will try and fix the error if possible and, if not, the game will just continue."

    Source

    The judge was right, you didn't resolve your spells fast enough, but not in terms of physical movement, but in terms of making the game state irreparable to "unresolve" them. The only way your logic would hold is if Chalice of the Void was a may ability.
    You mean like this one, from the link you just posted, and is the standing rules on how to handle missed triggers?: "Your opponent gets to decide whether he or she wants the trigger to happen or not." -- If you miss a triggered ability and it's caught later, your opponent simply gets to choose. In Jeremiah's case, the judge was blatantly retarded and should have immediately asked if Jeremiah wanted the spell to resolve--to which Jeremiah would obviously want it to do so.

  2. #102
    Everybody's a jerk! You, me..........this jerk.
    Parcher's Avatar
    Join Date

    Jan 2006
    Location

    DuPont Circle
    Posts

    1,520

    Re: Cheating or clever use of the rules?

    Quote Originally Posted by Rock Lee View Post
    I am incredibly curious to who this was, and how little information they had about the gamestate or the game. But they couldn't be more wrong about what was happening at all.

    First off, Chalice is a trigger that can be missed. A good player will still try to resolve spells even into a chalice if it is their only out hoping that their opponent misses their triggers.

    Secondly, The brainstorm situation was entirely not accurate. My opponent said "ok" to my brainstorm, which both of us had been saying for the duration of our 3 games, so I go to start drawing cards, and then my opponent says "wait chalice!" and I look to the judge nexto me, who was watching our games because we were the last match, and say "he said ok, so do I get to resolve brainstorm?" and the judge says "No because you didn't pick up your deck fast enough." This infuriated me because 1. Magic is not a dexterity game and 2. My opponent using the same terminology that we had been using the entire match implied that my spell resolved, and only when I grabbed for my deck with brainstorm then on the stack, did he cry out. I then ask the judge why my speed for reaching for my deck determined if the spell resolved, and asked him if I had reached for it faster then it would have resolved? The judge then backtracks and comes up with a reason he realizes is part of the tournament procedure guidelines rather than his intuitive perception, and says that "ok" on the part of my opponent isn't sufficient reason for a spell to resolve. This is completely accurate, however we had been using the same terminology the entire match, and only when my opponent slipped up did they then take advantage of it. My opponent of course, realizing they could lose the match (as we were in game 3) insists that they were just "acknowledging the spell" with ok, and hadn't decided to resolve their chalice trigger or not. Complete bullshit.

    Thirdly, The crop rotation that I resolve through chalice in the next few turns was the same situation, where I announce it, he says "ok" so I jump for my deck. Since the judge is now ruling on MTG being a dexterity based game, I am going to follow the judge's rulings. Always adhere to what the Head Judge demands, even if it is wrong.

    Fourthly and lastly, anyone who thinks that going for wins through people missing triggers, something I have no qualms with doing that and will continue to ad nauseam, is morally reprehensible may be correct. But it is not against the rules of MTG. Maintaining your own gamestate is the onus of the player controlling the triggers. This isn't clever use of game mechanics or cheating. It is the rules of competitive play.
    What a crock of shit.

    You're not a cheater. That's good. Never saw anything to indicate that you were. And while the OP made it seem possibly a shady move, everything else posted has pretty much cleared that up.

    Doesn't change the fact that you actions were those of a petulant, entitled child. Is there any reason not to cast spells into a Chalice? Nope. In fact there are many reasons to do so. Of course, that is not what happened. You first took advantage of what you admit was an opponent who had been out of the game when the triggers change happened. One who probably had no way to know how to react to a missed trigger, if that is what happened. You say you have no problem doing this since it' within the rules. Fine. I disagree with this, and think it's a sad way to try to win, but it isn't cheating.

    But getting pissy about a ruling, and blatantly exploiting that player's lack of experience and rules knowledge in some half-assed infantile rebellion against what you percieve as an injustice is just pathetic. Sack up, be a man, and play the game how you know it should be. Regardless of whether or not he allowed a play result that physical speed or dexterity could have avoided, you know better. And your reasoning for attempting to continue that method of resolving plays is the worst sort of rationalization. You might not have broken the rules(though it looks like you did in trying to make your point), but you definitely showed your character. On a really, really small stage. Congrats.


    EDIT: I'm not going to remove this, but there is no way to know for certain the communication between the two involved players. Without that definite information, there is no way to lay any blame on anyone. If Rudolph was 100% certain at the time that his opponent was allowing his spells to resolve, than he didn't do anything wrong.
    Last edited by Parcher; 11-12-2013 at 03:45 PM.
    Quote Originally Posted by MacGruber View Post
    Look, I will suck your dick. I will suck your fucking dick. I will do it, just join my team. I’ll suck your dick. You can fuck me or get fucked by me. You can watch me fuck something. Just point at something, I’ll fuck it for you. Just tell me what you want me to fuck!
    ~ Team Unicorn Motto

  3. #103
    Freedom is just as essential as air
    Mockingbird's Avatar
    Join Date

    Jan 2013
    Posts

    282

    Re: Cheating or clever use of the rules?

    Quote Originally Posted by Kich867 View Post
    You mean like this one, from the link you just posted, and is the standing rules on how to handle missed triggers?: "Your opponent gets to decide whether he or she wants the trigger to happen or not." -- If you miss a triggered ability and it's caught later, your opponent simply gets to choose. In Jeremiah's case, the judge was blatantly retarded and should have immediately asked if Jeremiah wanted the spell to resolve--to which Jeremiah would obviously want it to do so.
    This whole mess falls onto the judge, I knew that from reading the opening post and Jeremiah's response. Even if it does the mess may also fall under Unsporting Conduct--Cheating if Jeremiah knowingly played his spells into Chalice of the Void with the conscious goal of resolving them through a missed mandatory trigger.

    Page 21--4.8 C and D sound similar to the situation that is being described.

  4. #104

    Re: Cheating or clever use of the rules?

    The moral of the story is that the word "Ok" is terrible, and you should get into a habit of saying "Resolves" or "No repsonses" when you want to say you are letting something resolve.
    Magic Level 3 Judge
    Southern USA Regional Coordinator

    Quote Originally Posted by frogboy View Post
    Battle with a ragtag crew of adorable misfits. Narcomoeba and Golgari Thug hook up before the end of the movie.
    Quote Originally Posted by Nihil Credo View Post
    Please be less rambling in your next post. I only bothered with figuring out what the fuck you were trying to ask because I took it as a challenge.

  5. #105

    Re: Cheating or clever use of the rules?

    Quote Originally Posted by Mockingbird View Post
    This whole mess falls onto the judge, I knew that from reading the opening post and Jeremiah's response. Even if it does the mess may also fall under Unsporting Conduct--Cheating if Jeremiah knowingly played his spells into Chalice of the Void with the conscious goal of resolving them through a missed mandatory trigger.

    Page 21--4.8 C and D sound similar to the situation that is being described.
    It isn't cheating. At all. From the original article you posted:

    On a brighter note, it is never an infraction to not mention a triggered ability you don't control. This change was made several months ago due to player feedback that told us players felt unnecessarily burdened by tracking their opponents' abilities. From what I can tell, it's been a popular move. As the opponent in a missed trigger situation, you are free to enjoy the benefits of silence. Of course, you are always free to point out a missed triggered ability if you want to.
    Page 21, 4.8 C and D also don't apply. Letting a creature die that shouldn't be dying misrepresents the game state, which is both player's responsibility. The Sword example doesn't apply either because an ability can't half resolve. This is the reason for the example. It actually is against the rules.


    Quote Originally Posted by Anusien View Post
    The moral of the story is that the word "Ok" is terrible, and you should get into a habit of saying "Resolves" or "No repsonses" when you want to say you are letting something resolve.
    That seems like the opposite of the moral. The moral seems to be that if you vaguely say "ok", you can get away with pretending that you didn't pass priority. To be clear, I think this is a terrible message.

  6. #106
    Pray for Rain
    Tammit67's Avatar
    Join Date

    May 2010
    Location

    Philadelphia, PA, USA
    Posts

    1,534

    Re: Cheating or clever use of the rules?

    Quote Originally Posted by Mockingbird View Post
    This whole mess falls onto the judge, I knew that from reading the opening post and Jeremiah's response. Even if it does the mess may also fall under Unsporting Conduct--Cheating if Jeremiah knowingly played his spells into Chalice of the Void with the conscious goal of resolving them through a missed mandatory trigger.

    Page 21--4.8 C and D sound similar to the situation that is being described.
    That isn't accurate at all. Knowingly playing your spells into chalice hoping your opponent misses the trigger is not cheating. Resolving the spell without giving your opponent time to announce the trigger is.

    Unfortunate as it may be, THERE ARE NO MANDITORY TRIGGERS ANYMORE. You are not allowed to forget your own triggers (that's cheating) and you do not have to remind our opponent of their triggers, whether the trigger says may or it does not. Look at the same document you linked, section 2.1. Read that and understand it.

    I myself have resolved a spell through chalice. It won me the game and now I regret it. Doing so made me feel like scum. However, my play was well within the rules.
    Matt Bevenour in real life

  7. #107

    Re: Cheating or clever use of the rules?

    Quote Originally Posted by The Doctor View Post
    That seems like the opposite of the moral. The moral seems to be that if you vaguely say "ok", you can get away with pretending that you didn't pass priority. To be clear, I think this is a terrible message.
    You seem to be forgetting that this exact thing has happened at the highest level on more than one occasion, on camera before. Where someone has done almost the same thing as Jereemiah did. And they weren't called out for being a rabid cheat OMGZ BAN HIMZ!!!!! The onus is on the player to remember his own triggers and to be clear. Pointing to a Chalice after you say, "ok," is acknowledging that Chalice's trigger happens. Anything else is unclear: if Jeremiah's version of events is true (and I have to admit, it sounds pretty plausible) then this was what was happening all match, and thus the shortcut was assumed to be, "resolves".

  8. #108
    banned

    Join Date

    Jul 2013
    Location

    black metal bed room
    Posts

    2,188

    Re: Cheating or clever use of the rules?

    Quote Originally Posted by Parcher View Post
    You first took advantage of what you admit was an opponent who had been out of the game when the triggers change happened. One who probably had no way to know how to react to a missed trigger, if that is what happened.
    I thought that players are obliged to know the game. I never knew it is my duty to learn them in process. Next time I'll go to a tournament, I'll ask my opponents what exactly they need to explain, and if I may be of some help. I may even give them few nickles or wash their dishes.


    Quote Originally Posted by The Doctor View Post
    That seems like the opposite of the moral. The moral seems to be that if you vaguely say "ok", you can get away with pretending that you didn't pass priority. To be clear, I think this is a terrible message.
    This.

    I'd really love to read judge's version, but hey, I already wrote I won't interfere, so lets do what I should do.

  9. #109
    Everybody's a jerk! You, me..........this jerk.
    Parcher's Avatar
    Join Date

    Jan 2006
    Location

    DuPont Circle
    Posts

    1,520

    Re: Cheating or clever use of the rules?

    Quote Originally Posted by Bed Decks Palyer View Post
    I thought that players are obliged to know the game. I never knew it is my duty to learn them in process. Next time I'll go to a tournament, I'll ask my opponents what exactly they need to explain, and if I may be of some help. I may even give them few nickles or wash their dishes.

    See, I actually do this with players that obviously don't know what is going on:

    ME: Sac Narcomoeba to Therapy. Resolve Bridge triggers.(sees Surgical in opponent's hand) Why didn't you Surgical my Bridges in response?
    OPP: Well, it wouldn't matter since the triggers were already on the stack.
    ME: That's not how Bridge works.(gets judge, and explains Bridge with judge present). Let's back up, Extract my Bridges, I'll name the same card with Therapy.

    This was in a small, local tournament, with an opponent who was familiar with the game, but not with some cards. I had no problem allowing the game to progress how it should have had he known some obsure wording on an old card in a foreign language in a fringe deck. Now, at Professional Rules, in a tournament setting against a player who should know better, I probably would have taken a different tact. Encouraging new, or inexperienced players is an integral part of propagating the hobby. Teaching them how to play better is an important part of that.
    Quote Originally Posted by MacGruber View Post
    Look, I will suck your dick. I will suck your fucking dick. I will do it, just join my team. I’ll suck your dick. You can fuck me or get fucked by me. You can watch me fuck something. Just point at something, I’ll fuck it for you. Just tell me what you want me to fuck!
    ~ Team Unicorn Motto

  10. #110
    Member

    Join Date

    Jun 2004
    Location

    Madison, WI
    Posts

    1,601

    Re: Cheating or clever use of the rules?

    Quote Originally Posted by Anusien View Post
    The moral of the story is that the word "Ok" is terrible, and you should get into a habit of saying "Resolves" or "No repsonses" when you want to say you are letting something resolve.
    This is something I'm bad about. If I'm deep in thought, I have a tendency to say 'ok', simply acknowledging that my opponent is putting something on the stack. I really need to get better about replacing "'ok' with 'thinking'. Not really a conscious thing though.

    If a judge told you something that you don't think is right, you should appeal. If they are the HJ or the only judge there, talk to them about it afterwards. If you are still not satisfied, contact their Regional Coordinator.
    Quote Originally Posted by Draener View Post
    You know who thinks it's sweet to play against 8 different decks in an 8 round tournament? People who don't like to win, or people that play combo. This is not EDH; Legacy is a competitive environment, and it should reward skill - more so than it does.
    Quote Originally Posted by Borealis View Post
    Plow their Mom every chance you get!

  11. #111
    Win or lose, it begins with...
    Arsenal's Avatar
    Join Date

    Mar 2007
    Location

    Milwaukee, WI
    Posts

    2,184

    Re: Cheating or clever use of the rules?

    I wish this judge could come in here and sort things out. A judge telling a player, "you didn't physically pick up your deck fast enough" doesn't sound like something that would be said.

  12. #112

    Re: Cheating or clever use of the rules?

    Quote Originally Posted by Parcher View Post
    See, I actually do this with players that obviously don't know what is going on:

    ME: Sac Narcomoeba to Therapy. Resolve Bridge triggers.(sees Surgical in opponent's hand) Why didn't you Surgical my Bridges in response?
    OPP: Well, it wouldn't matter since the triggers were already on the stack.
    ME: That's not how Bridge works.(gets judge, and explains Bridge with judge present). Let's back up, Extract my Bridges, I'll name the same card with Therapy.


    You, Parcher, are a sport.
    "I have heard the mermaids singing, each to each. I do not think they will sing to me." -T.S. Eliot

    RIP Ari

    Legacy UGB River Rock primer Click here to comment

  13. #113
    A short, sturdy creature fond of drink and industry.
    PirateKing's Avatar
    Join Date

    Nov 2011
    Location

    BEST JERSEY
    Posts

    1,815

    Re: Cheating or clever use of the rules?

    I just want to give Rock Lee credit for being called out and representing himself with a valid retelling of OP's story. I can live with never knowing the truth to this, but I want to at least give respect to stepping up.

  14. #114
    Big Fat Hard Kicks, Oh My God I Want That Shit!
    Technics's Avatar
    Join Date

    Apr 2011
    Posts

    368

    Re: Cheating or clever use of the rules?

    This is why I ALWAYS use "That's Fine" or "One Second... in response"

    "Resolves", and "wait", have always seemed too "un-friendly" for me. Also if the word OK ever comes out of my mouth, in the same breath it's "OK so your are targeting..." it's never in a "Thats OK" form, and always in an "OK, let me clarify the game state" way.

  15. #115
    Member

    Join Date

    Feb 2007
    Location

    San Diego
    Posts

    1,478

    Re: Cheating or clever use of the rules?

    <3 Parcher

  16. #116
    banned

    Join Date

    Jul 2013
    Location

    black metal bed room
    Posts

    2,188

    Re: Cheating or clever use of the rules?

    Quote Originally Posted by Parcher View Post
    See, I actually do this with players that obviously don't know what is going on:

    ME: Sac Narcomoeba to Therapy. Resolve Bridge triggers.(sees Surgical in opponent's hand) Why didn't you Surgical my Bridges in response?
    OPP: Well, it wouldn't matter since the triggers were already on the stack.
    ME: That's not how Bridge works.(gets judge, and explains Bridge with judge present). Let's back up, Extract my Bridges, I'll name the same card with Therapy.
    So what's the reason to play the game then?
    "Oops, were we too slow, little little? And the nasty ball ran away? Here you are! Hop! Oops! A goal! I love you, baby, your first goal..."
    If you're into charity, you may help homeless people. When I go to the tournament, I expect ppl to make mistakes and I expect them to take advantage of my own mistakes.

    Btw, I always explain rules to my opponents if they need/want to. I do it even on MWS which is a big waste of time, but nvm. You completely mised my point: I simply can't read minds too well yet, so I don't know what do the people don't know. It's not my duty to scrabble in their minds and guess what exactly they don't know/understand and waste MY time during a competitive game trying to read if they forgot some trigger or if they don't know the game. I won't baby-sit them and I expect them to act the same towards me.

    If you feel morally higher then me because of your tendency to play instead of your opponents, then so be it. But again, maybe you should run some charity instead of playing a game that is decided by luck and mistakes.

    Also: this whole affair is about something else (an alleged deliberate cheating, not to mention stupid one), so the Narcomoeba trigger has nothing to do with it. Fortunatey it's a claim against the claim by two ppl I don't personally know from a lgs I don't personally visit, judged by an unknown judge, so I won't care anymore. And I never should have cared...

  17. #117
    Site Contributor
    Esper3k's Avatar
    Join Date

    Dec 2008
    Location

    Houston, TX
    Posts

    2,057

    Re: Cheating or clever use of the rules?

    Quote Originally Posted by Norm View Post
    There was no "does it resolve?"
    I actually hate having to do this when my opponent uses the ever so vague "ok" because it sets off (or should, at least) warning bells in their head and lets them rethink things.

    However, thankfully, there will still be people who allow it to resolve even when you ask that question.

  18. #118
    Freedom is just as essential as air
    Mockingbird's Avatar
    Join Date

    Jan 2013
    Posts

    282

    Re: Cheating or clever use of the rules?

    Quote Originally Posted by Tammit67 View Post
    Unfortunate as it may be, THERE ARE NO MANDATORY TRIGGERS ANYMORE.
    I checked 2.1, anf am curious why the third bullet point doesn't apply. But really it doesn't get more clearer than all caps. And personally, I find it a little depressing.

  19. #119

    Re: Cheating or clever use of the rules?

    Quote Originally Posted by Parcher View Post
    See, I actually do this with players that obviously don't know what is going on:

    ME: Sac Narcomoeba to Therapy. Resolve Bridge triggers.(sees Surgical in opponent's hand) Why didn't you Surgical my Bridges in response?
    OPP: Well, it wouldn't matter since the triggers were already on the stack.
    ME: That's not how Bridge works.(gets judge, and explains Bridge with judge present). Let's back up, Extract my Bridges, I'll name the same card with Therapy.

    This was in a small, local tournament, with an opponent who was familiar with the game, but not with some cards. I had no problem allowing the game to progress how it should have had he known some obsure wording on an old card in a foreign language in a fringe deck. Now, at Professional Rules, in a tournament setting against a player who should know better, I probably would have taken a different tact. Encouraging new, or inexperienced players is an integral part of propagating the hobby. Teaching them how to play better is an important part of that.
    That's is a great attitude/approach to have especially in a more casual environment (like FNM at the LGS). I think it's also perfectly acceptable to help out one's opponent after the match has already been decided (the key is not coming off as a prick!)

  20. #120
    Win or lose, it begins with...
    Arsenal's Avatar
    Join Date

    Mar 2007
    Location

    Milwaukee, WI
    Posts

    2,184

    Re: Cheating or clever use of the rules?

    Does anyone on here personally know this judge? Would they be able to get him to post here and clear up the situation? The discrepancies between the two parties are extreme.

Thread Information

Users Browsing this Thread

There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)