[DTB] ChubStill (56 Land 4 Spore Frog.dec!)

[Nihil Credo]

Or my bad English didn't allow me to understand the irony...

Every non-French knows that French people eat only frogs.

[Rood]

This deck seems hella fun, but is it any good at all? I mean even a little? The critters are surprisingly solid and the spells fit the curve quite well. It wouldn't surprise me if this deck turned out to be kinda good.

I would apretiate knowing its matchups and how much it would cost to build.

My guess is it COULd be okay but it would need a bit of improving from my original list. Plaxcaster is a good idea to start like others said, and maybe even another Omnibian? Also I'm not entirely sold on Daze in this deck it could probally be Spell Snare, instead. Also it's probally the most fun of any deck, possible ever? Spore Frog beatdown I mean come on that's brokenly awesome!

HAIL CHUB TOAD.

[frenchy-man]

Every non-French knows that French people eat only frogs.

Ok. French people are the lone people not to know it then ;-)

[syssc9]

LOL! It could also be all you Toad, er, frog players have your tounges planted firmly in cheek. Didgeridoo indeed!

[Skeggi]

Every non-French knows that French people eat only frogs.

WRONG! They also eat snails...

[Pulp_Fiction]

Now the only way someone could play this deck is with 4x FOIL SPORE FROG in it!!! If your deck doesn't contain at least 2x copies of foil Spore Frogs then you have no business playing it!! Generally against something like Goblins when you go turn 1 Tropical Island, FOIL SPORE FROG their unoriginal deck can not take the holy awesomeness that is the FOIL FROG!!

[Skeggi]

Generally against something like Goblins when you go turn 1 Tropical Island, FOIL SPORE FROG their unoriginal deck can not take the holy awesomeness that is the FOIL FROG!!

QFT

[xsockmonkeyx]

My guess is it COULd be okay but it would need a bit of improving from my original list. Plaxcaster is a good idea to start like others said, and maybe even another Omnibian? Also I'm not entirely sold on Daze in this deck it could probally be Spell Snare, instead. Also it's probally the most fun of any deck, possible ever? Spore Frog beatdown I mean come on that's brokenly awesome!

HAIL CHUB TOAD.

Plaxcaster is not as good as here, as the the only frog you really want to protect is the one that's gonna get Berserked. But, sadly, it is decidedly better than the mighty Chub Toad. Anurid Barkripper and Anurid Scavenger might be good, I dont know. But definitely not together. Pro:black is a lot more useful than Pro:blue. Bonesplitter might be better than Unstable Mutation here. You can strap a bunch of Rancors and Bonesplitters on pretty much anything and beat face.

[GenioDeArena]

Plaxcaster is not as good as here, as the the only frog you really want to protect is the one that's gonna get Berserked. But, sadly, it is decidedly better than the mighty Chub Toad. Anurid Barkripper and Anurid Scavenger might be good, I dont know. But definitely not together. Pro:black is a lot more useful than Pro:blue. Bonesplitter might be better than Unstable Mutation here. You can strap a bunch of Rancors and Bonesplitters on pretty much anything and beat face.

You are true on the Anurids. As the deck is now, -2 Chub toad for Anurid scavenger seems right. Old schol UG control allways used recursión as gaeas blessing, The spore deck is aggro-control and can attack with a engine recicler.The deck allready runs enogh shufling effects to make spore frog a recurring anoyance.


-Cant catch what you cant see-

[Skeggi]

As the deck is now, -2 Chub toad for Anurid scavenger seems right.

Seems wrong to me: the deck would lack The Chubb. Honestly, if you worry about things being good, put back in the goyfs.

[zulander]

Wait... so this deck doesn't actually play 56 lands? wtfever this is ghey.

[NQN]

You`re french, obv it´s the second reason.

[Rood]

You are true on the Anurids. As the deck is now, -2 Chub toad for Anurid scavenger seems right. Old schol UG control allways used recursión as gaeas blessing, The spore deck is aggro-control and can attack with a engine recicler.The deck allready runs enogh shufling effects to make spore frog a recurring anoyance.


-Cant catch what you cant see-

But it's the Chubb!! Why would you ever cut him for anything other then cooler looking Chub Toads?

[GenioDeArena]

Oh come on!! Chub Toad is nice and has the cute factor going on, but casual is power within boundaries. Ill make the scavenger a 3 of just because.

[Ghostfire45]

this entire deck is casual. Not playing chub toad is like not playing the collest guy in the deck. Anurid Scavenger is good though.

[xsockmonkeyx]

Here's my list, go forth and beatdown with amphibians:

// Lands
2 [IA] Island (2)
4 [ON] Wooded Foothills
1 [IN] Forest (1)
4 [ON] Polluted Delta
4 [b] Tropical Island
1 [DIS] Breeding Pool
4 Mutavault

// Creatures
4 Plaxcaster Whatever
4 Anurid Scavenger
4 [PY] Spore Frog
1 [5E] Chub Toad
1 [DIS] Omnibian
1 Bloated Toad
1 Whiptongue Frog

// Spells
4 Bonesplitter
4 [b] Berserk
4 [AL] Force of Will
4 [FNM] Rancor
4 [5E] Brainstorm
4 [NE] Daze

I decided to move away from total Chubb beatdown and adopted more of a toolbox approach which, of course, you tutor up with divine intervention. Berserk + Spore Frog is svg.

EDIT: I finally decided to go with Plaxcaster as it is blue and thereby can be pitched to Force of Will if you need to pay it's alternate cost. That kind of synergy can't be ignored.

[HammafistRoob]

Bloatedb Toad is fucking insane!!!!
I think I'm going to mash this deck together with Dreadstill and play my 120 card deck with a smile.

EDIT- I'm so fucking hapy taht this deck got it's well deserved DTB status. Took long enough...

[Rood]

It's true, Bloated Toad is TEH WINZORs. He gives you immunity to Pongify srly that's broken in itself because Pongify is EVERYWHERE amirite? And hell, he cycles when he's dead (although I can't ever see this happening as he's teh busted.)

[thefreakaccident]

This deck is actually like way better than dreadstill... Like seriously, no joke.


EDIT: Is this like hulk-flash # 4 now or what?!

[Skeggi]

EDIT: Is this like hulk-flash # 4 now or what?!

Yeah, but without the Hulk, or Flash...and with Frogs, and alot more awesomeness.