Just started playing ichorid here, so I might not actually see all the subtle aspects of your choice. I'm wondering though, how often do you need firestorm once you are already able to use DR? I thought the card was meant mainly to protect your bridges before starting to dredge too heavily, or as a removal against random stuff like yixlid jailer or samurai of the pale curtain (so in 95% of cases, before you can actually play DR). Same thing goes for chain of vapor. If you really want an out against moat/propaganda mid-combo with DR, why not play wispmare in the SB (which also gives you one more answer to LLotV)?
wow, took me almost a whole week reading everyones discussion on this deck starting from page 1. I was curious hat this deck was as I've never seen it, and when I used magic work station to play around with it I find it to be pretty interesting. I've also ordered the deck and waiting for the cards to arrive, but I've a few questions to those thats more expereinced with the deck, all I have been doing is just play testing for 40+ games on MWS, can't really call that experience =/.
But anyways, I am still waiting for my deck and a bunch of other cards I may find some use later, to come by. But currently heres what I have in mind.
4 Cephalid Coliseum
4 Gemstone Mine
4 City of Brass
4 Lion's Eye Diamond
4 Bridge from Below
1 Flame-Kin Zealot
1 Eternal Witness
4 Golgari Grave-Troll
4 Stinkweed Imp
4 Golgari Thug
4 Putrid Imp
4 Narcomoeba
4 Ichorid
4 Breakthrough
3 Deep Analysis
3 Dread Return
4 Cabal Therapy
Just the basic structure. Though I am a bit lost between the whole Eternal Witness vs Cephalid Sage, and the Street Wraith argument. Everyone sure brings up some good points.
My question though, if anyone can help me out. How do you pressure your opponent to blowing up his crypt, who is waiting for you to fill up your graveyard with more cards... and he can be... very very patient....![]()
Which is a friend of mine I play test with at one time online that uses the classic UW Landstill build. He sits there and waits for me to fill up on my graveyard before blowing up his crypt, and he is very patient about it... which makes me more impatient.
Are there certain conditions you should meet before pressuring with ichorids? like trying to get 1 bridge in graveyard first? Or an Imp to be casted to join ichorid in attacking. Should I try to achieve ThreshThreshThreshThreshThreshThreshThreshThresh? The one game I played him I had 1 ichorid I was bringing back and forth with 1 bridge in the yard, and he is sitting there with a crypt, crucible of worlds and cump blocking with factories. That time I ran out quickly of food for ichorid.
I know I am pretty noobish, but I had no idea what to do to presure the landstill player to crack the tormod's crypt. I was worried if I go all out with draw/dredge he nukes my graveyard.
I am new to this deck, and was hoping I can get some advise on how you guys go about pressuring someone (whose very patient) to cracking his crypt, especially landstill player.
Thank you.
Crypt baiting basically comes down to putting things in there that will kill him if he does nothing and will slowly progress your dredging, while at the same time your hand contains cards that will get you right back in. I usually harrass my opponent something along the lines of: attack with a lonely recurring Ichorid and a Bridge, while dredging a Thug, and playing and flashbacking Therapies while I can. Try to play the game but at a slower pace.
If your opponent plays a gazillion cantrips, or can search out Crypts, or can make it recurring (through Academy Ruins for example) you may want to be more aggressive; dredging faster to force him to use it, but always have some backup left in your hand! Otherwise you're in topdeck and that's a pain in Ichorid.
A Crypt or two with a good clock on your opponents side is usually very difficult to deal with though. But I've won games wherein my opponent succesfully activated three crypts. Remember that Putrid Imp is MVP, so is having two dredgers in your hand (so you get to keep one), hold on to Bridges if they're in your hand, etc.
What I noticed is that a lot of people don't even know when to blow up the crypt, but you shouldn't rely on that.
To disagree with a lot of people, I think Landstill is not such a great MU. They have multiple ways of dealing with your aggression and the slower you play them the more time you give them to set it up.
On the Ichorid recursion, I bring them back whenever it is beneficial for the game state. I won't bring it back if my opponent has a Propaghanda in play and I don't have the mana nor a Bridge in my yard. I'm also hesitant to recur it when it eats away my last dredger (which I usually try to avoid because Dredging hits more food).
Basically, Ichorid is awesome because he deals damage, is food for Therapy and Dread Return and makes tokens.
The situation you mentioned with the Factory, Crucible and Crypt is a difficult one though! It makes Ichorid underwhelming at the least. There're no conditions you have to meet before recurring Ichorids, just don't do it when it doesn't make sense to do it :)
This message has been deleted by Nightmare. Reason: Boo fucking hoo
In the case you mentioned with Factory, Cruicible and Crypt, if they have crypt doesn't that mean it's postboard so you would probably have chain of vapor / pithing needle? If you can stall long enough with Ichorid recursion and play either one they would have to sac the crypt. Or you can go with the strategy the guy above me mentioned if you don't have them in your hand.
Remember, the second most important aspect of Firestorm is that is can go to the dome. Especially since virtually no deck can completely stop Ichorid from dealing some damage. Also, swarm decks like Goblins and Elves can be troublesome because (among other reasons) they can produce enough creatures to consistantly block, and evasion is at a premium in this deck.
Wispmare is only excluded due to his sorcery speed. Against decks with discard and counters, the flexiblilty is simply more generically useful than the body+returnability of Wispmare. I run three enchantment removal spells plus bounce, but mostly for Leyline. Properly played, this deck can win through most hampering enchantments, but not a pre-game Leyline. While it is true that most decks are realizing that they cannot properly support a mulligan to Leyline, if they land it and you cannot answer immediately and through whatever disruption they can muster in addition to it, this is the one card you cannot with through. Plan accordingly.
How do you guys sideboard against Landstill on the draw ? I know I want to bring in Unmask, Tolarian Winds and Ray + Riftstone Portal. I'm thinking about taking out LED (because of Force) and Street Wraiths...I don't play Return, so I can't take that out ; )
georgjorgeGeistreich sind schon die anderen.
Good job, I am sure it helped you. Last weekend I entered an Ext. tournament with Ichorid - I goldfished it 200x and played 2/3sb once. Still I took 9th place out of 84..
It is really hard to play the deck on the MWS, because MWS is made to test Magic decks.. which Ichorid is not![]()
See above...![]()
Take out one Thug and try the Sage...
Oops.. not a noobish question, but rather a little bit hard..
First: Sometimes it is better to let the Ichorids lay in the GY, as they are harder to stop when they come in waves. You often find yourself in situations, when you need to make one or two dredges before skipping out, because opponent removed your Bridges recently.
OTOH, sometimes it is good to revive Ichorid even without BfB in GY and even if it could be blocked - e.g. you need it to sac for Therapy or DReturn. These situations are hard to specify in vacuum - this is where you must follow your experiences.
This is where we are getting near to your "how-to-crack-crypt" question.. See, you need to find the best speed with which you pilot the deck against Crypt. E.g. - you must keep opponent under pressure with Ichorids (and Moebas, PImps, whatever.., but mostly with Ichos) but in the meanwhile you cannot overextend, because he could easily remove most of your wincons by single Crypt.
This means that you need to dredge to continously find the fodder for Ichos. You may even interlace the Therapies somewhere, esp. if one or two Bridges are present. This will finally force him to crack the Crypt and by this time you may try go berserk with all those Breakthroughs, Deep Anals and DReturns...
The trick (how to force the Crypt to sac) is to keep your position a little bit better then that of your opponent.. but not m u c h stronger... because much stronger position means: lot of Ichorids cyclically coming outta graveyard, many Bridges in GY, lots of targets for DReturn, etc.. in short - giant GY... which is easily stopped by exactly that Crypt you fear...
Again, not that easy to answer this hypotheticaly - each game is different. (although I talk about Extended experience...)
BTW, this removed your Bridge, AFAIK...
You´re welcome.
at all: Tear me apart, if anything I wrote is wrong..
EDIT:
No one sides Wonder anymore against hordes?![]()
Most of us use rainbow lands which doesn't allow for us to play Wonder.
Pce,
--DC
Schadenfreude is the most genuine kind of joy, since it doesn't include even a drop of envy.Why can't we just admit it?
Firestorm is good at fulfilling the role you mentioned. It is also great at going to the dome for the last 3-7+ points of damage(mentioned above). Against decks like Goblins though you can't always rely on getting any use out of your Bridges at all and you're only route to victory is Ichorid beats and DRing a Troll. Firestorm really helps to keep the Goblin swarm in check and clear the way for your Ichorids (as well as providing an additional discard outlet).
awesome
Thank you for the response. Unfortunately I cannot add anything to the discussion until my deck arrives and I get a chance to play test it against real people, instead of solo play at MWS.
I haven't played this deck in a few months, but I like to start playing it again.
The Unmasks + Witness sounds really good, this is the list I'm going to test:
creature [25]
1 Eternal Witness
1 Flame-Kin Zealot
4 Golgari Grave-Troll
3 Golgari Thug
4 Ichorid
4 Narcomoeba
4 Putrid Imp
4 Stinkweed Imp
sorcery [16]
4 Breakthrough
4 Cabal Therapy
3 Deep Analysis
3 Dread Return
2 Unmask
enchantment [4]
4 Bridge from Below
artifact [4]
4 Lion's Eye Diamond
land [11]
4 Cephalid Coliseum
4 City of Brass
3 Gemstone Mine
Sideboard:
4 Chain of Vapor
4 Pithing Needle
1 CotV
2 Unmask
1 Akroma, AoW
1 Abeyance (Against Enchantress/Staxx/heavy permanent-control decks -> Return with Witness) *
2 Slots (E Truth/Firestorm/More CotV/Wax // Wane/?)
*I dont need Ray/Grudge because of this one
I never played leyline in my board, because I dont see the mirror enough to include it, and against decks with Fanatic (Goblins) and affinity you also want to board in 4Chain of Vapor/4Pithing Needle. Boarding out 8 cards is really bad for your speed, and thats not good against fast-aggro decks. I have Akroma + Ichorid beats when the Bridges are gonne..
Does someone who has more experience with a Unmask+Witness-list has some tips for it?
*Team Haste!*
In last lists if didn't see copies of careful study. Do you think that it doesn't worth?
Yeah, the Firestorms are better in aggro matchups. They can speed up your game and your clock, and as far as I know (clarification?) they allow you to discard cards even if it gets countered. That's important imo. It can wipe out your own Eternal Witness to reanimate it again also. I don't play akroma (even Reanimator doesn't use her any more. If you want a good beater then go with Simic Sky Swallower), I use Ancestor's Chosen in my board, as it's useful in many situations. If you get the right dredges (and this isn't a downside, hell, it's the way the entire list is), you can DR it to get out of Tendrils range, it's a 4/4 first striker, and it's really decent for the long game. Not SSS or Akroma, but it's nothing to sneeze at along with an army of Horrors and Zombies...
Unmask is for the Control matchup, where it's important to get the combo through before you get into the long game where most control decks thrive. The longer you wait to win, the more answers they draw, and the more likely you are to lose. Unmask paired with Cabal Therapy help aleviate this. Oh, you can go Therapy, DR Witness grabbing Therapy, Therapy again, and then flash it back sacking Witness.
I will probably never use Sage again. Or Leyline. I hated Leyline anyway; it was so damn clunky.
I'm not sure about the whole Careful Study; I hadn't noticed that some lists had dropped it...
You can drop Careful Studies game two in favor of Firestorms; as they serve the same purpose imo. They are a tad slower, but they get the job done and get some damage in as well.
SBing...Herm. I'll get back with you on that, I'm really too tired to address it right now. Parcher would probably know better than I would. I play against a lot more combo than anything, so SBing isn't exactly my fort'e.
Pce,
--DC
Schadenfreude is the most genuine kind of joy, since it doesn't include even a drop of envy.Why can't we just admit it?
Yes, the discard is part of the cost.
hmmm... I almost invariably side out the combo in a control match up. The Unmasks are great for stripping countermagic from the opponents hand, but their importance in the otherwise horrible combo match up should not be overlooked either.
awesome
I suppose it depends which control-type you are talking about. There are prison lists which I tend to go hard into for the combo quickly, and blue control that I side out the combo. That's how I play it. I sideboard in my 3rd Unmask against both. Against Blue control I side in Firestorm as it's an "uncounterable" discard spell, getting through both Chalice and CB and everything else, even if it is countered, you still get the discard. Against Prison lists I side in Chain of Vapors as well for graveyard hate, but I leave the combo in. I might be doing it wrong, but I don't have a lot of experience in the control match. Plus, it's worked for me.
Suppose I should have clarified this.
Pce,
--DC
Schadenfreude is the most genuine kind of joy, since it doesn't include even a drop of envy.Why can't we just admit it?
Can you cast breakthrough for a blue, then sac lions eye diamond to pay for 3 mana of its x value? I'm pretty sure you can't, but I just want to make sure.
No. You announce the X value when you announce the spell, then must pay all costs to pay that Breakthrough for X, before you can sacrifice Lion's Eye Diamond for mana. After the spell is paid for and on the stack, however, you can sac the LED to pay for anything that happens post-breakthrough.
Team Albany: What's Legacy?
You cannot know the sweetness of Victory, without first dwelling in the agony of Defeat.
I'm not sure I understand the necessity of Dread Returns at all (if that has already been discussed at length, maybe some-one can point me to the relevant pages). It seems like it works if I already have nearly half my deck in the yard, at which point I'm in a pretty good position anyway.
Of course I can imagine situations in which DR will win me the game while "normal" beatdown with Zombies and Ichorids won't, but do those situations really come up that often that they are worth sacrificing four or five slots for cards which neither discard a dredger, draw cards, or have Dredge ? In theory, I'd think those situations could mostly come up against Landstill, combo and maybe Goblins, but I can't think of much else...
georgjorgeGeistreich sind schon die anderen.
There are currently 2 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 2 guests)