Page 245 of 310 FirstFirst ... 145195235241242243244245246247248249255295 ... LastLast
Results 4,881 to 4,900 of 6196

Thread: [DTB] Vial Goblins

  1. #4881
    Member
    GoboLord's Avatar
    Join Date

    Apr 2010
    Location

    Germany
    Posts

    143

    Re: [Deck] Vial Goblins

    @ TossUs:
    I play Leyline of the Void too and I made the same experiences: It's simply awsome. It also has a surprise factor, since Reanimator and Dredge used to bring in Null Rod, Pithing Needle and Artifact removal expecting Crypt/Relic.
    I wouldnt play the new Leyline. IMO its only effective against storm-combo: ANT and Belcher.
    Right now ANT seems to transmute to NextLevelIggy which uses IggyLoop. Against this deck Ley-Line of the Void is killer enough, so you dont need the white one.
    This fact leaves Belcher as only deck to bring in the white Leyline against.
    I'd rather use those 4 slots for something that's more flexible than Leyline of Sanctity (like REB).

    @ jrw1985:
    As far as I know Rishadan Port is playable only in Mono R lists. If you splash B, G or even Bg and still have Ports you are too vulnarable to Wastelands. Plus: 7-8 colorless Lands in deck can bing you into trouble with manafixing.
    Well that's at least why I dont play them.

  2. #4882
    Your life total: 4, My life total: 20
    FoulQ's Avatar
    Join Date

    Jul 2008
    Posts

    230

    Re: [Deck] Vial Goblins

    I played leylines for a while in goblins. Then I stopped, for a pretty simple reason.

    The deck already needs to mull very aggressively (imo) to consistently win. Leyline makes you have to mull more. Some goblin hands are painfully mediocre and would lose to standard decks, but those hands can have leylines. The choice becomes: do I keep really bad hands with leyline, or do I mull a crazy amount more? Both options sound bad to me, and the extra benefit from leyline isn't worth it for me compared to traditional grave hate like crypt and relic, which can usually get the job done and which you can still flexibly mull for.
    Quote Originally Posted by Nihil Credo View Post
    The first time I heard of the site, I went to www.thesource.com and was greeted with a full-page picture of some thug pointing a gun at me. I immediately realised that Legacy was the most hardcore format ever.

  3. #4883
    Member

    Join Date

    Feb 2010
    Location

    Fürth, Germany
    Posts

    32

    Re: [Deck] Vial Goblins

    Quote Originally Posted by GoboLord View Post
    (1.)@ TossUs:
    [...]since Reanimator and Dredge used to bring in Null Rod, Pithing Needle and Artifact removal expecting Crypt/Relic.
    [...]
    I'd rather use those 4 slots for something that's more flexible than Leyline of Sanctity (like REB).

    (2.)@ jrw1985:
    a)
    As far as I know Rishadan Port is playable only in Mono R lists. If you splash B, G or even Bg and still have Ports you are too vulnarable to Wastelands.
    b)
    Plus: 7-8 colorless Lands in deck can bing you into trouble with manafixing.
    Well that's at least why I dont play them.
    Overall i have to agree:
    1.) I've never seen Null Rod played vs artifact hate. Whereas it makes sense esp. vs goblins and folks thanks to vial and i considered it myself while playing Ichorid, as an ichorid player it would be just suboptimal to play it.
    Chain of vapor and Nature's Claim get rid of all form of hate (yeah Jailer vs claim is obv.) while being castable on the first turn(s) and getting a discard outlet. The problem here is probably that noone is willing to discard the rod for breakthrough and stuff like that, therefore I would slow myself down by waiting to drop my anti-hate card.(mostly true for ichorid, not reanimator)

    So artifact or enchantment doesn't really matter.

    I have to confess that, lucky as i might be, i just faced reanimator like 3 times (standing like 6-3 vs it).
    Anyhow i never boarded ANY GY hate.
    Their only true outs seem to be sphinx (they will pull ahead easily after it) and Archon.
    Don't be afraid of Iona! You have ways to get rid of her, yes she will win a game or two for them ( i've managed to handle her more often than getting beat by her) but overall you have 3 turns to find a solution.

    The reanimator player expects us to board in GY hate boarding in his 2nd Show&Tell.

    See above lines regarding the creatures: i board REB and Anarchy instead to their expectations.
    Anarchy gets rid of all creatures that matter, REB makes sure that ours will deliver and/or our hate comes through.

    So, yes, i only bring in GY hate vs ichorid and lands (+blood moon).

    2.)
    a) this mainly depends on how many you are playing. I would go with 2 ports if i had them, this leads to
    b) main point why i still haven't bought them

    Quote Originally Posted by FoulQ View Post
    I played leylines for a while in goblins.[...]

    The deck already needs to mull very aggressively (imo) to consistently win. Leyline makes you have to mull more.[...]
    True, the mulligan decisions are my only real problem with the leylines. But as said before: i only bring in leylines vs lands and ichorid and from my point of view these are the decks where they are better than the artifacts and worth mulling into.

    Vs thresh or "variations" (counting New Horizons as such) I would love to have relics, but you can beat those decks w/o GY hate. Here i simply prefer perish instead of the hate and REBs ofc.

    My SB as reference:
    SB: 4 Leyline of the Void
    SB: 2 Perish
    SB: 1 Nature's Ruin
    SB: 2 Anarchy
    SB: 3 Red Elemental Blast
    SB: 2 Blood Moon
    SB: 1 Pyrokinesis

    I'm not talking about that anyone should just grab it, but i've been quite pleased with it.
    One Earwig is main, but he's not there to fight combo, that's a bonus, i mostly use it to get rid of progenitus preboard and my most preffered card to pick: Jitte. I scrapped the combo matchup, while some cards are still useful, nothing is really there to fight combo.
    Esp the board sweeper count is really high with 3 perish and 2 anarchy but there is no matchup where i bring in all 5, most of the time there is something different being simply better while not lowering your goblin count that much.

    And also my meta shifts between weeks like nothing else, so this is basicly vs random, although i've not seen ichorid in high numbers anymore. So maybe i'll drop some of the hate.

    Greetings, i hope noone feels offended

  4. #4884
    Site Contributor

    Join Date

    Jun 2010
    Posts

    138

    Re: [Deck] Vial Goblins

    Had to share this.

    Warchief, Matron #1, Piledriver #1 in play.

    Played Matron for Waste and Badlands to get Stingsourger

    Taiga to play Stingscourger, bouncing his 8/8 Terravore.

    Taiga to play Piledriver #2.

    Full attack and the chat on the side takes place.

    Roflz.


  5. #4885
    Member
    jrw1985's Avatar
    Join Date

    Jul 2010
    Location

    Kapa'a HI
    Posts

    412

    Re: [Deck] Vial Goblins

    Quote Originally Posted by daPaule View Post
    True, the mulligan decisions are my only real problem with the leylines. But as said before: i only bring in leylines vs lands and ichorid and from my point of view these are the decks where they are better than the artifacts and worth mulling into.

    Vs thresh or "variations" (counting New Horizons as such) I would love to have relics, but you can beat those decks w/o GY hate. Here i simply prefer perish instead of the hate and REBs ofc.

    My SB as reference:
    SB: 4 Leyline of the Void
    SB: 2 Perish
    SB: 1 Nature's Ruin
    SB: 2 Anarchy
    SB: 3 Red Elemental Blast
    SB: 2 Blood Moon
    SB: 1 Pyrokinesis

    I'm not talking about that anyone should just grab it, but i've been quite pleased with it.
    One Earwig is main, but he's not there to fight combo, that's a bonus, i mostly use it to get rid of progenitus preboard and my most preffered card to pick: Jitte. I scrapped the combo matchup, while some cards are still useful, nothing is really there to fight combo.
    Esp the board sweeper count is really high with 3 perish and 2 anarchy but there is no matchup where i bring in all 5, most of the time there is something different being simply better while not lowering your goblin count that much.
    I thought I'd chime in with my 2 cents on the SB. Here's what I'm running---


    My SB as reference:
    SB: 4 Leyline of the Void
    SB: 4 Leyline of Sanctity (They're on preorder)
    SB: 2 Perish
    SB: 1 Anarchy
    SB: 2 Krosan Grip (I'm running 2 Taiga maindeck)
    SB: 1 Shattering Spree
    SB: 1 Pyrokinesis

    Here's my thinking on SB card choice--
    Leyline of the Void is awesome. Mulling to it is worth it because it slows your opponent down until they find an answer or work around it.

    Leyline of Sanctity looks awesome. I don't have white mana sources in the deck, but I figure it's still the best possible pick against combo. Mindbreak Trap was too vulnerable to discard, and discard was too slow for a 1st turn Belcher game 3. I realize DePaul basically concedes that combo isn't his game, but I think sideboards should exist to help you win the match-ups your main deck is not supposed to. I'd take these over REB any day. We'll see how they play out once they arrive.

    Perish for Tarmagoyf.

    Anarchy for, yah know, stuff. It's great against enchantress, rhox war monk, Moat, often Zoo... so why not?

    K Grip 'cause I splashed Green. Duh. People just don't see it coming when you avoid the Taigas game one.

    Shattering Spree helps against those guys that feel a need to play all the artifacts.

    Pyrokinesis is there to replace a Weirding in the Mirror.

    I realize my SB is weak againt Merfolk, but I've never worried about that match-up as removal and draw on my side greatly outweighs the control and pump on their's. Absconding from REB means I'm more susceptible to countermagic, but I've never been too worried about that anyway. If my one drop gets Dazed or FoWed I'm still winning in the mana denial and card advantage game.

    But, I'm rambling...

    ONE MORE THING-
    Why the hell does everyone play Blood Moon? It's practically worthless against anything but 43 Lands. It's slow, and game 2 everyone starts playing around your Wastelands by fetching basics before you can even get your Blood Moon in play! I don't get why anyone plays it in SB.

  6. #4886

    Re: [Deck] Vial Goblins

    @ jrw1985 and daPaule

    how is 1x pyrokinesis working for you guys? It's weird.. but interesting..
    if it's for the mirror.. what else do you guys bring in? I tried RB Goblins, but it was really bad in the mirror...
    Maybe because I liked weirding a little too much..

  7. #4887
    Member

    Join Date

    Feb 2010
    Location

    Fürth, Germany
    Posts

    32

    Re: [Deck] Vial Goblins

    Quote Originally Posted by jin View Post
    @ jrw1985 and daPaule

    how is 1x pyrokinesis working for you guys? It's weird.. but interesting..
    if it's for the mirror.. what else do you guys bring in? I tried RB Goblins, but it was really bad in the mirror...
    Maybe because I liked weirding a little too much..
    I bring it in for the mirror and Merfolk. Last time i still played 2 Kinesis & just one Anarchy.
    Kinesis is so so. As said my meta shifts alot and also the numbers are varying from 9 - 45 (yes it really is weekly legacy :)).

    Last time Blood Moon and Leyline were completely dead while playing vs NO surv Elves (perish & kinesis here kinesis won me game 3), Deadguy (nothing really, duh but tried kinesis cause of confi), Dreadstill (REBs) and Solidarity (REBs).

    Sometimes I simply can't decide whether i should bring in blood moon or perish. If playing vs supreme blue (or other 3c+ decks with goyfs and rhox) you could use both, while you don't really want to change the MD at all :( While blood moon slows them down IF it hits, they mostly still have firespout so you are forced to play a steady game and not overextend that much.
    So normally i go the perish & REB route.
    By now i know who might bring lands and scout better before a tournament so freeing up the 2 slots from blood moon.

    Also i want to try out a sharpshooter, either main or SB cause elves are on a rise right now.

    Considering the white leyline vs combo: what does it do to stop him comboing ?
    After he used nauseam, meditates, glimpse... he just might draw into bounce, or his chances to tutor for it afterwards are alot better. You might have the suprise factor g2, they might just expect artifact hate. But as you can see in almost every combo deck thread: flexibility is what they are looking for in the board and bounce is almost better than plain artifact hate, so u might still get the "splash damage". Though you might get a turn out of it which nets you the same what a thorn does, while not slowing you down by paying for it and it's faster.

    Last time i played vs soli i mulled all 3 games, 6,5 and 4 cards i think. While never having a REB or a fast start anyway (or lands..). So this was just the deck fucking with me. If i'd hit a leyline at this stupid hands at least, yeah it would have been ok.

    Anyhow after turn1 you have 3 dead cards in your deck :(

    greetings

  8. #4888

    Re: [Deck] Vial Goblins

    Quote Originally Posted by daPaule View Post
    I bring it in for the mirror and Merfolk. Last time i still played 2 Kinesis & just one Anarchy.
    Kinesis is so so. As said my meta shifts alot and also the numbers are varying from 9 - 45 (yes it really is weekly legacy :)).

    Last time Blood Moon and Leyline were completely dead while playing vs NO surv Elves (perish & kinesis here kinesis won me game 3), Deadguy (nothing really, duh but tried kinesis cause of confi), Dreadstill (REBs) and Solidarity (REBs).

    Sometimes I simply can't decide whether i should bring in blood moon or perish. If playing vs supreme blue (or other 3c+ decks with goyfs and rhox) you could use both, while you don't really want to change the MD at all :( While blood moon slows them down IF it hits, they mostly still have firespout so you are forced to play a steady game and not overextend that much.
    So normally i go the perish & REB route.
    By now i know who might bring lands and scout better before a tournament so freeing up the 2 slots from blood moon.

    Also i want to try out a sharpshooter, either main or SB cause elves are on a rise right now.

    Considering the white leyline vs combo: what does it do to stop him comboing ?
    After he used nauseam, meditates, glimpse... he just might draw into bounce, or his chances to tutor for it afterwards are alot better. You might have the suprise factor g2, they might just expect artifact hate. But as you can see in almost every combo deck thread: flexibility is what they are looking for in the board and bounce is almost better than plain artifact hate, so u might still get the "splash damage". Though you might get a turn out of it which nets you the same what a thorn does, while not slowing you down by paying for it and it's faster.

    Last time i played vs soli i mulled all 3 games, 6,5 and 4 cards i think. While never having a REB or a fast start anyway (or lands..). So this was just the deck fucking with me. If i'd hit a leyline at this stupid hands at least, yeah it would have been ok.

    Anyhow after turn1 you have 3 dead cards in your deck :(

    greetings
    What I meant was what else besides pyrokinesis do you bring in against the mirror..
    and also how often did you draw it if you only had 1-of...

    I wouldn't expect to need to bring in anything against the folk..
    but some people like to add icing to the cake..

  9. #4889
    Member

    Join Date

    Nov 2009
    Location

    Seattle, WA
    Posts

    168

    Re: [Deck] Vial Goblins

    Quote Originally Posted by daPaule View Post
    I bring it in for the mirror and Merfolk. Last time i still played 2 Kinesis & just one Anarchy.
    Kinesis is so so. As said my meta shifts alot and also the numbers are varying from 9 - 45 (yes it really is weekly legacy :)).

    Last time Blood Moon and Leyline were completely dead while playing vs NO surv Elves (perish & kinesis here kinesis won me game 3), Deadguy (nothing really, duh but tried kinesis cause of confi), Dreadstill (REBs) and Solidarity (REBs).

    Sometimes I simply can't decide whether i should bring in blood moon or perish. If playing vs supreme blue (or other 3c+ decks with goyfs and rhox) you could use both, while you don't really want to change the MD at all :( While blood moon slows them down IF it hits, they mostly still have firespout so you are forced to play a steady game and not overextend that much.
    So normally i go the perish & REB route.
    By now i know who might bring lands and scout better before a tournament so freeing up the 2 slots from blood moon.

    Also i want to try out a sharpshooter, either main or SB cause elves are on a rise right now.

    Considering the white leyline vs combo: what does it do to stop him comboing ?
    After he used nauseam, meditates, glimpse... he just might draw into bounce, or his chances to tutor for it afterwards are alot better. You might have the suprise factor g2, they might just expect artifact hate. But as you can see in almost every combo deck thread: flexibility is what they are looking for in the board and bounce is almost better than plain artifact hate, so u might still get the "splash damage". Though you might get a turn out of it which nets you the same what a thorn does, while not slowing you down by paying for it and it's faster.

    Last time i played vs soli i mulled all 3 games, 6,5 and 4 cards i think. While never having a REB or a fast start anyway (or lands..). So this was just the deck fucking with me. If i'd hit a leyline at this stupid hands at least, yeah it would have been ok.

    Anyhow after turn1 you have 3 dead cards in your deck :(

    greetings
    Combo prepares for the possibilty of you playing pillar as well, so bounce will be brought in (along with any artifact specific hate). It doesn't stop them from comboing, and therefore doesn't really give you another turn. Chalice actually does give you time, and does stop them from comboing.

    Against the mirror, your chances have less to do with what you sb but more of what you maindeck. Having more incinerators gives you a better matchup. You could play that Goblin that gives all of them +3/+0 until end of turn and then kills them to increase your chances in the mirror. Other than that, it comes down to die roll, draws, and playing ability.

  10. #4890

    Re: [Deck] Vial Goblins

    Quote Originally Posted by JonBarber View Post
    Combo prepares for the possibilty of you playing pillar as well, so bounce will be brought in (along with any artifact specific hate). It doesn't stop them from comboing, and therefore doesn't really give you another turn. Chalice actually does give you time, and does stop them from comboing.

    Against the mirror, your chances have less to do with what you sb but more of what you maindeck. Having more incinerators gives you a better matchup. You could play that Goblin that gives all of them +3/+0 until end of turn and then kills them to increase your chances in the mirror. Other than that, it comes down to die roll, draws, and playing ability.
    Pyromancer? Yeah I do play him. He's pretty awesome even not in the mirror. I side him in randomly. It's true though, it is what you main deck and not what you sideboard. Back when I was the only one left playing Mogg Fanatics, it reminded me how much I missed them since they were so good in the mirror. Apparenly goblins can't really answer first turn lackey either..

  11. #4891
    Member

    Join Date

    Jan 2007
    Location

    Birmingham, AL
    Posts

    122

    Re: [Deck] Vial Goblins

    Quote Originally Posted by jin View Post
    Apparenly goblins can't really answer first turn lackey either..
    Lightning Bolt is pretty sweet for this too, since usually goblins doesn't have a play that can stop a first turn lackey if they have incinerator.

  12. #4892

    Re: [Deck] Vial Goblins

    Quote Originally Posted by markbris View Post
    Lightning Bolt is pretty sweet for this too, since usually goblins doesn't have a play that can stop a first turn lackey if they have incinerator.
    I really have to chime in here and point out that lightning bolt is just awful in goblins. There is no reason to ever dilute the deck with non-goblins. If your making consesions to playing against the mirror you are doing it wrong unless you can reasonably expect to play against goblins at least twice per tournament in your meta. The added consistancy which come from playing all goblins is far superior to whatever minor utility you get from playing lightning bolt.

    As far as zoo goes if you want to beat zoo upping your weirding count and playing all four incinerators is the way to go. One of the main keys is to avoid trying to outrace them since they have burn and instead maximizing your card advantage since we have way more than they do. If played properly goblins can actually be the control in this matchup.
    declaring war on magic ignorance since 2009.

    for the record i have no good ideas. im just pointing out yours are terrible too.

  13. #4893

    Re: [Deck] Vial Goblins

    Quote Originally Posted by markbris View Post
    Lightning Bolt is pretty sweet for this too, since usually goblins doesn't have a play that can stop a first turn lackey if they have incinerator.
    Yes, I know. You can check out my list 2 or 3 pages back. I wouldn't say bolt is THE solution, but it is A solution. I wouldn't play bolt for that reason though. I play it because it is good removal and it has good reach to finish games.

    Quote Originally Posted by yadda View Post
    I really have to chime in here and point out that lightning bolt is just awful in goblins. There is no reason to ever dilute the deck with non-goblins. If your making consesions to playing against the mirror you are doing it wrong unless you can reasonably expect to play against goblins at least twice per tournament in your meta. The added consistancy which come from playing all goblins is far superior to whatever minor utility you get from playing lightning bolt.

    As far as zoo goes if you want to beat zoo upping your weirding count and playing all four incinerators is the way to go. One of the main keys is to avoid trying to outrace them since they have burn and instead maximizing your card advantage since we have way more than they do. If played properly goblins can actually be the control in this matchup.
    Goblin HAS to play the control aspect to win. I don't think it is a question. At first I thought Lightning Bolt would be awful too, but after some more testing, I really wouldn't call it diluting the deck. Goblins used to play up to 24 lands. I'm sure adding in 3 non goblin cards while cutting 2 lands wouldn't hurt the deck that much. As I stated earlier, I have tried a more burn oriented build. You can check out my list a few pages back. It's not too bad, you should try it out. It's pretty bad-ass to win through game 1 Moat and still be able to fight Zoo and Goblins. Now all I have to do is learn to beat combo.. LOL

  14. #4894
    Your wife likes my cow.
    pater's Avatar
    Join Date

    Mar 2005
    Posts

    450

    Re: [Deck] Vial Goblins

    Quote Originally Posted by yadda View Post
    I really have to chime in here and point out that lightning bolt is just awful in goblins. There is no reason to ever dilute the deck with non-goblins. If your making consesions to playing against the mirror you are doing it wrong unless you can reasonably expect to play against goblins at least twice per tournament in your meta. The added consistancy which come from playing all goblins is far superior to whatever minor utility you get from playing lightning bolt.

    As far as zoo goes if you want to beat zoo upping your weirding count and playing all four incinerators is the way to go. One of the main keys is to avoid trying to outrace them since they have burn and instead maximizing your card advantage since we have way more than they do. If played properly goblins can actually be the control in this matchup.
    I've been having the argument with myself for the last few weeks about Lightning Bolt. I've been trying to fix the number of removal spots to 7-8 and figure out how to fill them with Goblin-based removal. Currently I'm set with...
    3 Lightning Bolt
    3 Warren Weirding
    2 Gempalm Incinerator

    My reasoning for Bolt is simple, any opening hand with Lackey and Bolt brightens my hope for the game. Opening hand Bolt is 90% of the reason I run it, because I fully understand the pain of Ringleadering over one and the rarity of naturally drawing (or Gempalming into) one. Warren Weirding is the second best removal card for Goblins IMO, and it's also nifty when someone drops Iona on red and you just Weirding it. If I wasn't running Bolt, Weirding would easily become a 4-of, and yes, I have tested Stingscourger and Tarfire.

    The bottom line is, I don't run Bolt to help the Zoo matchup, it just helps. It is there to help enable Lackey/Instigator. Every removal spell in Goblins should be there above-all to enable Lackey. Gempalm seems like the only exception, but only because of how monstrous it can be turn 3/4/later.

    I do agree with you about the control aspect of playing against Zoo, but Bolt is definitely not "awful" in Goblins and Bolting a Kird Ape is not a "minor utility".
    Quote Originally Posted by FakeSpam
    EDIT: 2 mods post in this thread. Where's Matt P when you need him.

    EDIT2: I love men......

    right here buddy...

  15. #4895
    Member

    Join Date

    Aug 2005
    Location

    Kennesaw, GA
    Posts

    13

    Re: [Deck] Vial Goblins

    From my tournament report thread on this site (go read it!)


    Lightning Bolt doesn't go into your hand when you cast Ringleader/Matron. The more non-goblin cards you add to the deck, the weaker the synergy becomes and the weaker your inevitability is. I think this is a mistake that a lot of Goblin players make; adding cards that seem like they help, and wind up diluting the entire deck so that is in fact weaker.

    Gempalm, on the other hand, is just a great card in the deck. So much so that I added another before STL. It isn't as good as it used to be, because now we have all these 3 toughness creatures for 1 mana, but that doesn't make it cuttable my any means, IMO. I have won games and matches because of the removal as well as the cycling ability by itself. It is all about synergy, and Gempalm has that in spades. Being able to tutor up a cycling removal spell is a great feeling.
    Also, I wouldn't play the deck without Rishadan Port. The card is really really good at one of goblins' main paths of attack: mana disruption.

    I also completely disagree with the previous posted about removal being all about enabling Lackey. I often think of connecting with Lackey as a bonus, not a needed thing in order for the deck to work. I think the THREAT of connecting with Lackey is often enough to change the way other people play in your favor. While Goblins can come out of the gate super-fast, most games rarely let you just swing away unimpeded; you are in it for the mid-game in which you have a synergistic card advantage engine unlike any other deck in the format. To run the deck as a purely aggressive deck is limiting the amount of games you can win, IMO. Also, I have just been very unimpressed with Instigator (as I mentioned in my report); it just doesn't do enough on its own vs. decks that play cards that affect your permanents.

    -AA

  16. #4896
    Member
    TheSleeper's Avatar
    Join Date

    Apr 2010
    Location

    Himalayas
    Posts

    113

    Re: [Deck] Vial Goblins

    Can anyone comment on my list? As should be obvious, its tweaked to be better against Aggro. My meta has other Goblins, Zoo, DnT, Mono-Black, Bant, all kinds of aggro.

    4 Aether Vial
    4 Goblin Lackey
    3 Mogg War Marshal
    4 Goblin Piledriver
    4 Stingscourger
    3 Gempalm Incinerator
    4 Goblin Matron
    4 Goblin Warchief
    2 Goblin Chieftain
    4 Goblin Ringleader
    2 Siege-Gang Commander
    18 Mountain
    4 Wasteland

    Based on meta information, should I be including Port? I do own a playset. If so, how many? I was thinking -1 Mountain, -1 Stingscourger, +2 Port - is this optimal? In testing I have found that while not very aggressive, War Marshal really helps in chumping early on before you just overrun them with your card advantage. I would love to run Weirding etc but have no access to those dual/fetches atm.
    Only the heroic and the mad follow mountain goat trails.

  17. #4897
    Your life total: 4, My life total: 20
    FoulQ's Avatar
    Join Date

    Jul 2008
    Posts

    230

    Re: [Deck] Vial Goblins

    @ TheSleeper, here is what I think, whether you like my thoughts or not is up to you of course.

    4 Stingscourger? That freaks me out a little bit. I actually think he is best against aggro-control decks more than aggro, decks that rely on fatties to win: Aggro Loam, Countertop, etc. They rely on their creatures for defense and stingscourger is great at catching them with their pants down, thinking that goyf wall will delay the game. Stingy shows up and BAM you are now at the top table. Still, for any meta I wouldn't play 4, 3 is the max for me. You usually only want one a game. Gempalm is great with the "swarm" variant of goblins (mogg war marshal + chieftain mini-combo that goes well with piledriver/SGC/gempalm). I'd go up to 4, and possibly 4 MWM to be honest. And possibly another goblin chieftain.

    That being said, Mono-Black/DNT/Goblins!? Is it time for the reappearance of...mogg fanatic!?

    I'd put 2 more chieftain in your sideboard for the mirror (with about even hands he wins the game) as well as 4 pyrokinesis.

    Now, I know people have a curiously bisexual relationship with their piledrivers, but your meta sounds like aggro heaven and piledriver could be reduced to make room for other cards for your meta. But only one, I'd say, you always want 3 piledrivers in the deck most games, even post SB I'd say.

    And lightning bolt looks pretty nice for that meta. But it requires some getting used to.

    If you handed me that deck and I had a tournament in an hour at your meta, here's what I would do:
    -1 Piledriver
    -1 Stingscourger
    +1 Gempalm
    +1 MWM

    You don't need black to be good in an aggro meta. In fact I prefer MonoR or RW, and in fact specifically for your meta RG (tsh...kills vial/jitte. plus kgrip against the control decks built to counter the aggro meta, and maybe compost to laugh at the silly mono-black masochistic goths) with what you described. Weirding isn't very good against zoo, I don't know what people are smoking, but pass it to me please. Stingscourger is awesome because it leaves a body you can throw into zoo just like MWM. But you know that. With 7 between scourger/MWM you are maximizing out this strategy and focusing your deck which is nice.

    Overall your list looks pretty hawt. You don't really need port, and I wouldn't go up to 23 land for it. Not worth the dead draws when you need business fast against all the aggro decks. -2 mountain, +2 port maybe. I played with 2 ports for a long time and liked it before I started playing instigator (still do think he's awesome). The only way you'll know if you like it is if you try it in a tournament, everyone seems to have a different perspective on ports. Port might be getting better post-Columbus, if the meta shifts to make control viable again like some people are saying. I'd like to point out that old-school landstill simply didn't lose to portless goblin lists. Getting people off UU for Jace or R for firespout or B for plague, etc, well, it's gonna be very important if the meta goes where the obvious predictions lead.

    Bring in pyrokinesis against zoo PLEASE don't listen to the naysayers. It's not as good as perish, but your list makes up for the lack of perish with 4/3 sting/MWM. It IS the second best sb tool against zoo behind perish.

    The SB I'd scrap together before the event started would be something like this (keeping in mind my personal md changes),
    4 Pyrokinesis (hard to argue against this?)
    2 Goblin Chieftain (plague's coming back....I called it here first...also helps in non-goyf aggro matchups a ton of course)
    1 Goblin Piledriver (come in against bant, possibly mono-black depending, also any control decks built to counter the aggro meta)
    4 GY Hate (can't go wrong with this imo)
    1 Goblin Pyromancer (mirror, also against control decks and decks like burn where you have dead removal MD)
    3 Pithing Needle (pretty good, especially if people predict the aggro meta and bring control decks with deeds and the like)

    The main problem with the decklist? No answer to jitte. I've tried everything in MonoR: pithing needle, my own jittes, tinkerer, goddamn goblin freaking VANDAL, but they all suck. The best answer is usually pyrokinesis in MonoR. But that often isn't good enough. If you do lose to jitte, you will have to deal with your wily opponent going over to his friends saying, "I don't get some people, why do they play goblins when it singlehandedly loses to jitte," well go tell that dumbass DnT or mono-black player (playing his deck from like what 2005) that HE WOULD LOSE TO JITTE AS WELL. Tell him, NEWS FLASH, aggro decks lose to jitte all the time.

    ....ETA: So then comes the larger big picture question. "If I can splash, what is the best way to handle jitte?" People will usually say to just splash red-black blah blah but NO. Tin Street Hooligan is NUTS in aggro metas.

    1. Effective answer to jitte. And tinkerer IS NOT.
    2. Effective answer to vial. Great tempo swing, especially because your opponent was probably relying on that vial.
    3. People don't usually see it coming (people are dumb and play mono-black still remember)
    4. Effective answer to generic artifacts that control decks pack to stop aggro decks
    5. Usually there is a target that isn't meaningless, even if your opponent has no jitte/vial/etc.
    4. The art is awesome, the quote is surprisingly funny, and he's a hooligan just like me. I can relate to his antics.

    And now, I'm about to admit something. Just don't laugh at me. My personal pet peeve probably in all of magic is when people slyly point out, "I don't like how warchief and TSH interact." They think they caught some grand error in my thinking. What's funny about this is that when people say that, they make it clear that they have never tested TSH. If you have a warchief in play, you usually don't need TSH. I playtested a kajillion cames with RG over the course of a couple months and the interaction was soul-crushing like three times. So for one more time I will say, TSH + WARCHIEF IS NOT A PROBLEM.

    I know the RG splash isn't that popular on the forums, but for the right meta like yours I highly recommend it.
    Quote Originally Posted by Nihil Credo View Post
    The first time I heard of the site, I went to www.thesource.com and was greeted with a full-page picture of some thug pointing a gun at me. I immediately realised that Legacy was the most hardcore format ever.

  18. #4898
    Member
    TheSleeper's Avatar
    Join Date

    Apr 2010
    Location

    Himalayas
    Posts

    113

    Re: [Deck] Vial Goblins

    Wow FoulQ.. that was an epic response, more than I could have hoped for - thanks!! It definitely is an aggro feast at the moment in my area atm. The SB guide was great too, because right now I just have Kinesis, Anarchy, Blood Moon and Thorn -> probably not ideal for what I'm facing.
    Only the heroic and the mad follow mountain goat trails.

  19. #4899

    Re: [Deck] Vial Goblins

    @ FoulQ

    Informative post. It was really detailed. I'd like to try TSH too, but I can't afford Taigas right now. Tuktuk Scrapper doesn't even compare.

    With the mono-red list though, I'd have to agree that simply keeping your opponents off creatures is enough to win through jitte. I hven't played with pyrokinesis in awhile so I don't know how well that works, but I average about 8-9 removal with every Goblin deck I make so I never felt like I needed Pyrokinesis. What good is a jitte if there isn't anyone to weild it right?

    One thing I'd like to point out though: Related to the black splash, I don't think it is the weirding that people like but the parish.

    I also have to disagree with your readiness to drop port. Like daze, port has the ability to buy a turn or two and that is important if you plan on racing someone that kept a questionable and/or hateful hand. Just something I'd like to remind you all when your Monoblack playing oppoent is all ready to drop plague on your third turn now has to drop it turn 4. And goblins CAN kill turn 4..

  20. #4900
    Member
    TheSleeper's Avatar
    Join Date

    Apr 2010
    Location

    Himalayas
    Posts

    113

    Re: [Deck] Vial Goblins

    Can Goblins kill on turn 4 if you spent turn 3 porting them tho? Regardless I don't believe Port would be strongest against a mono-coloured deck like MBC (they might run Ritual regardless). I see it more against something like Zoo/Loam/Bant where in addition to Wastelands, you can keep them off a colour for awhile and slow their development.
    Only the heroic and the mad follow mountain goat trails.

Thread Information

Users Browsing this Thread

There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)