Yeah a lot of the lists posted on here I don't agree with so I just ignore them. But yours I liked more and I was high so hell, why not respond. Plus you gave a good meta list which makes the card choices soo much easier to work with. People sometimes say "what about card XXX," well it kinda depends on the meta for if card XXX is good (within reason, some ideas are just bad and some are obviously good)...meta is everything.
Anyways back to the discussion at hand.
Yeah I don't really like anarchy that much for DnT. I don't have much experience from that deck, I just know it as a white vial aggro deck that has a lot of unique tricks. But my main problem with it is that anarchy is not as good as pyrokinesis...yes it kills all white creatures, but the casting cost difference is a gigantic factor in the vial mirror. Just think about it, what would be better SB material against merfolk (vial aggro that can maximize tempo like us and DnT): pyrokinesis or blueanarchy? I would rather have pyrokinesis.
Expensive spells are just really bad in goblins compared to as other decks. Anarchy's effect is powerful and useful but I would say moreso against controllish decks rather than DnT or something like bant I suppose.
Thorn is only worth it against combo. I tested it against some other decks...burn, canadian, even landstill...it's bad.
Blood Moon isn't really that great against aggro decks, especially aggro decks where you have to take the control role in the beginning (including zoo) because it does nothing to develop your board position that you need to battle for hard in the beginning. It can even blank against zoo sometimes in a way. Yes, it will hose zoo sometimes, but I'd rather have a consistent stream of goblins.
Against loam decks it's really good though. And those might show up if your meta really is that aggro.
@jin: If you can't afford taigas then screw it. RG is best in vial metas...ofentimes undeveloped but sometimes not, where there are lots of aggro decks that are designed to prey on decks that "time stop" themselves (if you haven't read the famous article you should). This includes stuff like Goblins, Merfolk, Counterslivers, etc. but extends to pretty much every aggro deck in legacy, especially monocolored ones that can't pack an answer to everything and have to answer opposing questions in more inventive ways.
That's one reason why I've stuck with goblins so long. It's a lot harder to find good cards for the SB and sometimes the MD, but in the end its so much more rewarding to problem solve in deck construction with this deck than other legacy decks. With other legacy decks its like...have a problem with enchantments? Throw in krosan grip. Not liking the combo/control matchup? Get some spell pierces up in the hood! Sick of all those creatures? Splash red and play firespout. Talk about BOOORING, we're playing old school cards like goblin pyromancer, pyrokinesis, and hell only 6 months ago I had patron of the akki in my sideboard once in a while.
I hate TukTuk Scrapper, I think that card blows and sucks. 4 mana is ridiculous. I need to answer a jitte pretty much immediately or it won't matter if it destroys me. And the bigger overcosted ass doesn't do much in goyf.format (an mws joke ha.ha.ha.). No artifacts in legacy are worth the mana investment, and if they are in your meta than stop playing goblins, usually when I have 4 lands I want to be casting ringleaders or warchief + crazy shenanigans NOW.
Yes, after testing against and with jitte I agree that the best solution is to kill the guys holding it,and the easiest way to do that (especially when the opponent takes you by surprise of course) is with pyrokinesis most of the time.
With weirding I think it is actually sort of BAD in the matchup. I would board it out on the draw, especially if I have a sideboard metagamed against zoo. You are not going to have enough removal, you just have to overextend your ass off, it's the easiest way to win, and no zoo sideboard packs pyroclasm anymore, thank GOD (their best card against us imo because our easiest route to victory is overextension). Weirding is a tempo sink. If your opponent goes t1 nacatl t2 creature, killing off one guy on your second turn is going to result in the zoo player still smashing your face in pretty hard, especially if your board is empty or limited. I mean it is alright but I don't grip the weirdings in my hand in the matchup thinking about how precious they are like I do to my ringleaders, vials, and wastelands.
Yeah, if you can manage to find it here on the forums you can see I was one of the last ones to drop port. But it's just like an ex-girlfriend, get away from it awhile and you'll see that the single (in this case portless....lol "port") world isn't so bad.
What's awesome about port is that it takes advantage of people's tendency to play less lands in legacy. When is port best? Obviously when vial is in play, but it also really shines when your opponent gets stuck on a land.
I once played a guy who kept a 1-land hand playing canadian threshold with 2 basics (island/forest). He fetched up a volcanic and bolted my lackey all cocky-like, shuffling his hand around at mach speed and eyeing the board like he was thinking way harder than I could even think about thinking. Well a wasteland and many turns later he was left with a basic forest in play and then along came port. I was getting flooded but it didn't freaking matter, I was porting a basic forest!! That's LOLZ! And then he played another land and then I wastelanded that one too. A few turns later and goblin goon swept in for the win (what my naive self at the time thought must have been the greatest card ever against aggro-control).
Also winning with port feels awesome. Your opponents get SO pissed and get mad at their decks and they will cry about how unlucky they are. It reveals any closet douchebags: anybody who has to bitch and moan because they kept a land-risky hand against a port and some pressure (ex. cocky ANT players.. OHHH WAIT TOO SOON?).
Goblins can kill on turn 4 with a vial or two if you port on turn 3 I'm pretty sure. And your opponent might have given you that chance by keeping a bad hand that had a plague. But it's still kind of a dream scenario imo.
But yeah port is good and you could probably get away with running only 16 mountains, you run no instigators, only 2 chieftains and the MWM/Stingy save you time to find the second mountain. You should test out 16/4/2 (or 17/4/2) and see what happens, you can always go back.
ETA: I never really meant to compare serenity vs anarchy, I was saying that serenity doesn't look that bad if the metagame does shift in the obvious way. They fill two entirely different roles really. I just kind of PMS when people say certain splashes are strictly better than others. Might be true for some decks and sometimes even for goblins, but everyone's meta is different.
Originally Posted by FakeSpam
Lands (22)
* 5 Mountain
* 4 Wasteland
* 4 Rishadan Port
* 4 Bloodstained Mire
* 3 Badlands
* 2 Taiga
Goblins (33)
* 4 Goblin Warchief
* 4 Goblin Matron
* 4 Goblin Piledriver
* 4 Goblin Ringleader
* 4 Goblin Lackey
* 3 Gempalm Incinerator
* 2 Siege-Gang Commander
* 2 Stingscourger
* 1 Goblin Sharpshooter
* 1 Kiki-Jiki, Mirror Breaker
* 1 Wort, Boggart Auntie
* 1 Lightning Crafter
* 1 Goblin Chieftain
* 1 Skirk Prospector
Spells (5)
* 4 AEther Vial
* 1 Warren Weirding
Sideboard (15)
* 3 Perish
* 2 Blood Moon
* 2 Patriarch's Bidding
* 2 Naturalize
* 2 Relic of Progenitus
* 2 Back to Nature
* 1 Extirpate
* 1 Tormod's Crypt
This is the deck my friend suggested I start swinging my build towards, and testing it out on MWS I like it alot, but I have questions about Kiki-Jiki.
If I tap him to copy lightning crafter, championing himself. Tap lightning crafter to deal 3 damage. Sacrifice the lightning crafter token to Skirk Prospector. . .does Kiki-Jiki come back into play untapped?
So that forms an infinite combo thats instant GG. . . and unlimited red mana but thats besides the point =p
@ pater, what do you side the 4 REBs in for exactly? Just wondering I've always thought it was a strange decision whether to board it against some FOW decks. And like I was saying, I really wanted to find an effective answer to jitte in MonoR but there really isn't one, even stretching to cards like goblin vandal, yes. It got that desperate. In the end pyrokinesis is best probably.
@ Neuad, personally I'm not a fan of that combo as it makes your deck more inconsistent. What I like about goblins is that it is a consistent aggro deck compared to many other legacy aggro decks IF (and only IF) the goblins player knows how to properly mulligan and doesn't puss out of mulliganing. All the somewhat situational 1-ofs I don't like, because there is rarely a reason to tutor them over ringleader. The only 1-ofs I like are stingscourger, chieftain, tin street hooligan, possibly gempalm/weirding, SGC in a tight list, etc...cards that you would tutor for sometimes, and randomly drawing them could save you in tight situations. Otherwise I aim for consistency, t3 matron/warchief --> t4 ringleader/swarm.
I would replace naturalize with krosan grip if I were you, the extra mana cost is well worth it.
Personally I think you guys are a little wacko for liking a 5cc situational sorcery requiring BB, maybe against the most dedicated of control decks but otherwise I'm staying away from that.
Also I really don't like your manabase. If you are going to play 4 ports in a RBG build you definitely need at least 23 lands, probably 24. Which is why most people don't do it, at least not 4 ports. You are going to have trouble finding your splash colors probably, especially because: you will need to crack your mires oftentimes immediately, making it difficult to decide for mountain/badlands/taiga... it is harder for goblins to sit on fetches than other decks, because they need consistent land drops early to be able to set up the mid/late game with ringleader. It really sucks to lose to your own manabase with goblins, especially since YOU are supposed to be screwing up theirs.
My meta has alot of blue, so yeah, mostly it targets early FoWs that try to stop Vial. Anything with blue is always loaded with counters, so it helps. There doesn't seem to be anything else really.
What do you run instead? Mainboard Pyrokinesis? Can't think of any other way to kill 2 blockers on T2. Gotta work with what we got. Perish comes in to help against Zoo, but I prefer Weirding over Stingscourger for alpha strike.Originally Posted by jin
Originally Posted by FakeSpam
You play REB to counter a FoW on an "early" Vial? That means you are waiting until turn two to play vial, and you're still tapping out into a possible daze. A turn three vial isn't exactly early, so I'm not reeing the use here. REB for Rhox War Monk or against Merfolk, on the other hand, is good.
Also, in what way is Weirding better than Stingscourger for the alpha strike? You choose the target with scourger AND its a guy that gets to swing in if you have a warchief/chieftain. I won't debate the usefulness of Weirding and its Edict effect, but I just feel like Stingscourger is a much better alpha strike card.
Hey guys,
This is my Vial Goblins deck.
Land - 23
2 - Taiga
2 - Rishadan Port
3 - Badlands
4 - Bloodstained Mire
4 - Wooded Foothills
4 - Wasteland
4 - Mountain
Other - 8
4 - Ęther Vial
4 - Warren Weirding
Creatures - 29
1 - Wort, Boggart Auntie
2 - Warren Instigator
3 - Gempalm Incinerator
3 - Siege-Gang Commander
4 - Goblin Ringleader
4 - Goblin Warchief
4 - Goblin Lackey
4 - Goblin Matron
4 - Goblin Piledriver
Sideboard - 15
2 - Pithing Needle
2 - Extirpate
3 - Krosan Grip
4 - Cabal Therapy
4 - Leyline of the Void
Im trying to make the deck as fast as possible (as one would with gobo's) Does anyone see any problems at all that I may have missed?
Any comments at all?
Cheers
Err, I tried Pyrokinesis back in 2008.. maybe? I just run stingers/gempalms/fanatics (now bolts). I play a mono red list though. Why would you need to kill two blockers on turn two? Why would they have two blockers on turn two? Why are they so damn fast.. LOL. I don't really like pyrokinesis since you lose card advantage more often than not.
I don't understand. How is weirding better than stinger for the alpha strike?
Amen.
On the draw, a resolved lackey would probably destroy you. If you want it to go faster, maybe some Goblin Pyromancers are in order.. LOL. I think zoo will be pretty tough without Perish or Mogg War Marshal.
You seem to be very ready for reanimator though.. LOL.. dredge.. a bit of combo hate there too... anti equipment and CBT.. moat/humility. Your Kgrips might have to go overtime against thopter foundry decks though seeing you'd probably have to hit Counterbalance, Sensei's Divining Top, Humility, Thopter Foundry, etc.
You might wanna fit anarchy/perish into your side board.. and maybe Tin Street Hoolagin in the main?
In regards to my decklist above; would it be better for my decklist to run like this:
Main:
- 2 Instigators
+2 TSH
SB:
- 1 Pithing Needle
- 2 Extirpate
- 4 Cabal Therapy
- 4 Leyline of the Void
+ 3 Pyrokinesis
+ 4 Perish
+ 4 Anarchy
4 Anarchy in the side is definite overkill. Since you splashed green, Krosan Grip takes care of all the scary white enchantments anyways (such as Moat, Humility, COP:Red, etc). The most troublesome white creature I can think of at this moment is RWM, and Perish takes care of that already. I believe Anarchy is only used in MonoR decks since they have no way to get rid of said white enchanments and creatures.
Also, if you're cutting Instigators, you should probably trim SCG to 2 since with five 4-drops and three 5-drops, your hands are going to be a little clunky.
@ Pyrokinesis
For those playing with Pyrokinesis in your SB, what cards do you usually side out for it? Also, what cards do you usually end up removing from your hand in order to play the Pyrokinesis?
@ partyx2000: I don't think it would necessarily be "better." You should test it if you have time, to see what's it like. But everyone prefers different things, ya know?
I will say that I tested a lot of goblin sideboard cards, extirpate being one of them. It's bad, especially if it is not a 4-of (because then it has some decent usage against say...loam).
Personally I wouldn't dare have 0 gy hate in my sideboard for pretty much any legacy deck. I love me somes graveyard hate. I fucking HATE graveyards.
4 Anarchy is a lot, I see mainly 2-3, 4 anarchy seems excessive or is that just me?
If you really want speed than x4 pyrokinesis in sideboard. It's FREE casting cost!!
Kiki-Jiki was a late game winner for me. Simply amazing card nobody should pass up as a one of in your deck.
. . . . . Josh?
And for whats its worth. SCG > Kiki-Jiki > Copy Siege Gang commander for a free chump blocker, and 3 awesome goblin tokens.
I did it today, twice! Kiki-Jiki chump blockers saved my board as I got the firepower to clear theirs and win the game!
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)