Page 111 of 140 FirstFirst ... 1161101107108109110111112113114115121 ... LastLast
Results 2,201 to 2,220 of 2789

Thread: [Deck] Burn

  1. #2201

    Re: [DTB] Burn

    Quote Originally Posted by kirbysdl View Post
    Two points; Flame Rift just speeds things up. If you're playing against an inherently faster deck, it's bad. E.g. Storm needs 2 fewer Goblin tokens or 2 less Storm count for a lethal Tendrils. If you're playing against an inherently slower deck, it's good.
    I find this to be a half-truth, as I would say that, in the cases where you're playing against combo decks, Flame Rift wouldn't necessarily be bad, but won't surely be as easy to play, as it will then require the proper timing. Whatever happens, Flame Rift is still 4 damage for two mana, and addressing the recoil it has is just a matter of management - though it might not always be manageable.

    Kind Regards,
    jares

  2. #2202

    Re: [DTB] Burn

    Quote Originally Posted by kicks_422 View Post
    Figure of Destiny is a polarizing card that defines whether you're Burn or Sligh. It's a pretty big tempo loss with a potential for a massive (well, in Sligh terms) beater, but it fits more into a Sligh mentality. A deck with a Burn mentality wouldn't run it, and go with the Hellspark Elementals of the world.

    Note that I said Sligh/Burn mentality, not a Sligh/Burn deck. I've been playing Sligh since it's earliest forms (even wrote this primer), and the player's mentality goes a long way into defining the deck that you're playing as Burn or Sligh - even when you're running the same cards as another dude with the same 75 cards.
    I find that running Figure of Destiny doesn't necessarily define whether the deck is Burn or Sligh (given that the deck that it's being considered for in this discussion has already been predefined as "Burn"), but it does open up an avenue/option/alternative for Burn to adapt to a Sligh-oriented line of play whenever the situation calls for it.

    I liked that you pointed out that "Sligh" is a mentality more than anything - though, I would prefer to call it a "philosophy". One card, or one line of play doesn't make a deck "Sligh" - it's the philosophy that makes the deck (whether Burn or Sligh) the way it is. From time to time, Burn decks will be presented with the situation where a Sligh-oriented line of play would be best, and Sligh decks would also encounter situations where the Burn philosophy would be more beneficial. Either way, Burn will still be Burn, and Sligh will still be Sligh, and having the option to "borrow" lines of play from each other will certainly be a good thing.

    Cheers,
    jares

  3. #2203

    Re: [DTB] Burn

    Quote Originally Posted by jares View Post
    I just realized something that I feel that every Burn player should consider when playing in the current meta game - most of the Tier decks have a means of gaining life via their main deck:

    All the other Tier Decks (Sneak Show, Reanimator) are already difficult match-ups to begin with (except maybe for RUG Tempo), which means that, given these premises, the majority (if not the entirety) of the field is well-prepared to combat Burn.

    Having said that, I believe that Sulfuric Vortex has become an excellent meta choice, and I've realized that I wouldn't compete in the current meta without it - I'll surely use at least [2x] in the main deck.

    Cheers,
    jares
    I agree. Out of all of the things that cripple burn, lifegain is one of them. I have yet to see anything better than Sulfuric Vortex. 2 in the main, 1 in the side, drop the random shard volley, go up to 20 lands?

  4. #2204

    Re: [DTB] Burn

    Quote Originally Posted by DragoFireheart View Post
    I agree. Out of all of the things that cripple burn, lifegain is one of them. I have yet to see anything better than Sulfuric Vortex. 2 in the main, 1 in the side, drop the random shard volley, go up to 20 lands?
    That sounds okay, but note that having 20 lands also concerns me, and I have been looking into going back to using Fetch Lands again (8x as of the moment) to address the deck-thinning issues, and also to fuel Grim Lavamancer.

    Running Fetch Lands has recently been abandoned because of the emergence of RUG Tempo decks running Stifle, and also because losing additional life could also affect the mirror match. While these are indeed valid concerns, I've found that the following points suggest that it's much less of an issue than it really is:
    • The probability that the deck you'll be going against runs Stifle: Unknown/Variable
    • The probability that a deck running a full set of Stifle will have it in the opening hand: 39.95%
    • The probability that your opponent will be on the play: 50%
    • The probability that you'll draw a Fetch Land in your opening hand, given that you're running 8x in the deck: 65.36%
    • The probability that you won't draw a Mountain in your opening hand (alongside the possibility that a Fetch Land is also drawn): 19.06%
    • Considering all the above points, this is the probability that you'll have issues with Stifle: less than 2.49% (given that we still have unknowns/variables, which can only be expected to lessen the probabilities)

    My calculations and considerations about Stifle might not be absolute, but the exploration of these details suggest that there is very little to be worried about when running Fetch Lands. As for the life loss, I expect to lose 1-2 life every game by running 8x Fetch Lands in the deck, and I find this to be a good bargain for being able to thin my deck of excess lands and fuel Grim Lavamancer in the process. The life loss will likely cause concerns in the mirror match, and this seems to me like it's the most weighted risk, one that I'm more than willing to take, as the mirror match is usually decided by whoever goes first anyway.

    I'd be very interested to hear everyone's thoughts regarding these considerations.

    Kind Regards,
    jares

  5. #2205

    Re: [DTB] Burn

    You don't need to jump to 20 lands to include Vortex, even 3 of them, in the MD. I run a LOT more 3 drops than anyone else and I get mana flooded just as often as screwed at 1 or 2 which is normally a sign that the number of lands is good. Carefull use of Magma Jets normally keeps things running smoothly.

    I've long been a pro-Vortex voice for the very reasons that so many top decks gain life. I also use the popularity of Jitt and Batterskulls, which gain life, supporting factors for including 2 Smashed to Smithereens MD. While I don't see the overall community coming around to that idea I guess I am not completely outside the norm now if everyone starts running 2-3 Vortexes MD.


    I still don't exactly see when Flame Rift is going to be good?
    Combo decks are faster and you tend to make it easier on them if you hit yourself for 4 damage.
    Fast aggro decks tend to kill just as fast as Burn so unless you kill them that turn with it, and not yourself, you are just as likely to put yourself in range to be killed on their turn.
    Slower playing control decks, do any of them not play life gain and/or heavy counters? The 1 spell they are likely to not counter is the 1 that also hits you.

    The reason behind most people including Flame Rift is speed up the clock. It doesn't do that. The fastest we can win is turn 3 and that not only doesn't include using Flame Rift, just by the numbers, it CAN'T. That means the only rational reason to include it is for the purpose of throwing a big bomb once you run out of other spells in your hand. By that point in the game (turn 4+) you have an idea if the 4 damage you take is likely result in you losing the game or not. To cast it on turn 2, unless you just have NOTHING else to play has to be the worst possible time to play it. Burn is just not that fast where you can assume you can race people while also giving up 4 damage. And hate to say it, but Legacy is only getting faster and faster, but unless they print a spell like "R: 6 damage to target player or creature, (and I assume a drawback like) 4 damage to you" we will never get faster then turn 3 kill.

  6. #2206
    Bear Cub > Tarmogoyf

    Join Date

    Jul 2007
    Posts

    775

    Re: [DTB] Burn

    Hell, I never get a turn 3 kill anyway with all the opposing disruption, mulliganning, etc. When I run Flame Rift, it is indeed to speed up the clock. But the theoretical maximum isn't what matters to me. If I can go from a 4.5 turn average to a 4.3 turn average with Flame Rift, and if the card won't be a liability in a lot of my matchups, then I'll run it.
    Most people blindly suggest new cards for decks. True contributors also suggest what to remove. It's not about what's good, but rather what's better than the current selections.

  7. #2207

    Re: [DTB] Burn

    Quote Originally Posted by RogueBuild View Post
    You don't need to jump to 20 lands to include Vortex, even 3 of them, in the MD. I run a LOT more 3 drops than anyone else and I get mana flooded just as often as screwed at 1 or 2 which is normally a sign that the number of lands is good. Carefull use of Magma Jets normally keeps things running smoothly.
    Going up to 20 lands is definitely not a requirement by any means, but it's a personal preference for me to increase the probability of opening with 2 lands in-hand, and to decrease the probability that I'll have a 3cc card but with only two lands in play. Magma Jet is indeed very helpful in these situations, but then again, it isn't a card that I would run either, for the reasons that have already been beaten to death.
    Quote Originally Posted by RogueBuild View Post
    I still don't exactly see when Flame Rift is going to be good?
    I believe that the discussion of this has already been beaten to death too.
    Quote Originally Posted by RogueBuild View Post
    Combo decks are faster and you tend to make it easier on them if you hit yourself for 4 damage.
    Fast aggro decks tend to kill just as fast as Burn so unless you kill them that turn with it, and not yourself, you are just as likely to put yourself in range to be killed on their turn.
    That is correct - dealing 4 damage to yourself will certainly make it easier for combo and aggro decks to finish you off, which is why, in these situations, Flame Rift needs to be played with caution and timing. For these cases, you will have to play Flame Rift on your fundamental turn, or if possible, on the turn where playing it would ensure a win.

    The drawback of Flame Rift is as obvious as it can be, and we need not beat the dead horse about it.

    What needs to be understood about Flame Rift is the simple fact that it progresses Burn's game plan very well as a direct-damage card that's cheap and powerful at the same time - Burn will never be able to get enough of the cards that fit this description.

    For all other considerations about its drawback, it will boil down to a matter of preference (for people that prefer to be "safer"), play style (for those that choose to use these slots to play more of the "transient creatures" at our disposal), and/or a meta choice (for obvious reasons). Forgoing the use of Flame Rift isn't necessarily a wrong choice, because I could think of scenarios where it would be a good move. It should be noted, though, that using it has proven to be effective (both theoretically and practically), as evidenced by the recent success of Burn decks that have all been running it.
    Quote Originally Posted by RogueBuild View Post
    Slower playing control decks, do any of them not play life gain and/or heavy counters? The 1 spell they are likely to not counter is the 1 that also hits you.
    This sounds like a good thing to me.

    Of all match-ups, the control match-up is the one where I would gladly trade my life total for dealing damage.
    Quote Originally Posted by RogueBuild View Post
    The reason behind most people including Flame Rift is speed up the clock.
    I hope that that's not the only reason for doing so, because that would be a very shallow reason by itself.

    Kind Regards,
    jares

  8. #2208

    Re: [DTB] Burn

    Quote Originally Posted by jares View Post
    you will have to play Flame Rift on your fundamental turn, or if possible, on the turn where playing it would ensure a win.
    which is exactly why I don't like the card. The window where you can use it effectively/safely is too narrow and it has no other secondary use. As I see it there is no instance where playing it on turn 2 would be a good idea so that makes it a turn 3+ spell. In that case, if I'm going to hit me and you and have a decent chance of having 3 lands I would rather get something else out of it. This is why I run Flamebreak and Volcanic.

    It really comes down to a different philosophy of Burn. We all agree that Burn can not race and win against combo. It is simply a fact. Unless they just get a crap draw or screw up all on their own they are just faster. Hell, some guy beat me 4 games in a row with him winning on T1. I never even drew in 2 of those games because I went 2nd. Re-Animator, unless you get you grave hate in your opening hand or drawn by turn 2 it will likely be too late. So when it comes to speed Burn is not a world class sprinter. Aggro decks tend to be 1 turn slower then us but a lot more consistent and many come pre-loaded with cheap counters or lifegain. They don't even have to counter anything or gain a single life, all that has to happen is we draw 1 too many lands and they overrun us. Speed wise they are even with us. These factors is why I don't play "brainless straight to the head" Burn. I accept the truth that I can't now, nor will I ever be, the fastest and play with that in mind. Play to the strengths of the deck concept. I feel as time goes on people will abandon the current philosophy or the deck as a whole because other decks are getting faster and faster and Burn has been stuck a best case god-draw of turn 3 kill for a very very long time and I don't see a 6 damage for 1 red spell coming any time soon.

  9. #2209

    Re: [DTB] Burn

    Quote Originally Posted by RogueBuild View Post
    As I see it there is no instance where playing it on turn 2 would be a good idea so that makes it a turn 3+ spell. In that case, if I'm going to hit me and you and have a decent chance of having 3 lands I would rather get something else out of it. This is why I run Flamebreak and Volcanic.
    This is an interesting take on things, which does makes sense, and will be one of those things that make each of our builds different. I remember that you're also not running Goblin Guide, which fits nicely with running Flamebreak (I personally would like to be able to play Flamebreak too, as I think that it's a really good card). I wish you luck with your build.
    Quote Originally Posted by RogueBuild View Post
    It really comes down to a different philosophy of Burn. We all agree that Burn can not race and win against combo. It is simply a fact. So when it comes to speed Burn is not a world class sprinter. These factors is why I don't play "brainless straight to the head" Burn. I accept the truth that I can't now, nor will I ever be, the fastest and play with that in mind. Play to the strengths of the deck concept. I feel as time goes on people will abandon the current philosophy or the deck as a whole because other decks are getting faster and faster and Burn has been stuck a best case god-draw of turn 3 kill for a very very long time and I don't see a 6 damage for 1 red spell coming any time soon.
    I agree that people should indeed abandon playing "brainless, straight to the head Burn", and should gain more experience on the intricacies of when to pay attention to the board - this might actually be more difficult than one might expect, especially since the nature of Rift Bolt, Chain Lightning, and Fireblast make this a bit more difficult. This is also why I've always liked playing Grim Lavamancer, as this creature improves our options in addressing the board whenever necessary (amidst all the other things that this creature brings to the table).

    I also agree that we should play to the "strengths of the deck concept" instead of diluting the deck with unnecessary preferences - unfortunately, being able to do this first requires an understanding of these concepts, something that doesn't seem to be too common anymore.

    This is probably why Burn has always had the reputation of being a "noob deck", and the reality is that many of us are indeed under-prepared in building and piloting this deck because we might not be taking enough time to study it inside-out. Although the range of decisions that have to be made in the game isn't too wide for Burn, I find that this archetype permits one of the smallest margins of error when played in a competitive environment, and this is why we need to study the archetype - to be able to manage that small margin more efficiently.

    As for what will happen to this archetype in the future, I prefer to always worry about the current meta, as that will always be the meta that we'll need to compete against.

    Cheers,
    jares

  10. #2210

    Re: [DTB] Burn

    Quote Originally Posted by jares View Post
    As for what will happen to this archetype in the future, I prefer to always worry about the current meta, as that will always be the meta that we'll need to compete against.

    Cheers,
    jares
    That is the KEY statement. You see my thoughts as referencing the future. I am saying I think we are at that point now. We know its coming. Aggro is already as fast as us and more consistent. Do we need them to be faster and winning on turn 3 before we adjust the philosophies? And I am not saying abandon the hopes for a turn 3 god hand kill or a turn 4 likely. I'ld say 85% of my wins still come on turn 4 or 5. The difference is I don't die on turn 5 or 6 from the army of creatures that got ignored as I hoped to kill you on turn 4 and drew a 4th land or got countered

  11. #2211

    Re: [DTB] Burn

    Quote Originally Posted by RogueBuild View Post
    That is the KEY statement. You see my thoughts as referencing the future. I am saying I think we are at that point now.
    I'm sorry, but I reviewed your latest posts, and I was unable to find the KEY statement that you're referring to. May I request for you to clearly state what you're trying to suggest here?
    Quote Originally Posted by RogueBuild View Post
    I'ld say 85% of my wins still come on turn 4 or 5. The difference is I don't die on turn 5 or 6 from the army of creatures that got ignored as I hoped to kill you on turn 4 and drew a 4th land or got countered
    Same here. I don't see the difference that you're referring to.

    Regards,
    jares

  12. #2212

    Re: [DTB] Burn

    I said people would either abandon the current all to the head philosophy (which is to basicly aim for the head and ignore everything else and hope you hit 20 damage before they kill you with creatures or gain life) or abandon the deck as a whole.

    You responded with "what will happen to this archetype in the future..." as to say the need to reconsider the philosophy of the deck might come about sometime later. And I think we are clearly at a point where due to the speed of non-combo decks we should adjust the game plan now and build with a turns 5, 6 and 7+ in mind. That's why my deck is the way it is.

  13. #2213
    Stackbuilder

    Join Date

    Mar 2012
    Posts

    859

    Re: [DTB] Burn

    Before cutting Flame Rifts, you should keep in mind, that people still play Leyline of Sanctity.

  14. #2214

    Re: [DTB] Burn

    If you where to go back to my build, which was posted about 9 or 10 pages ago I think, you would see I run plenty of things to get me around a Leyline as well as a CotV set to 1, and if I take my time I can get around Counterbalance. And my SB makes it even easier.

  15. #2215

    Re: [DTB] Burn

    Tournament Report. Stop reading if you hate Flame Rift.

    Anyways last night I played the Burn list in my last deck post. Of course with it being exam season at the university we were lucky to have 8 people out.

    First matchup: 9 land stompy.

    Game 1: I take it down with his Ghazban Ogre. I was on the play and I went turn 1 goblin guide. He went turn 1 Ghazban Ogre, Rogue elephant. I then on turn 2 attacked and he decided to take it. I kill the rogue elephant and on his turn the ogre is mine. no looking back from this I win.

    In 3 Pyrostatic Pillars Out: 3 Price of Progress

    Game 2: I have burn. no creatures in hand. in the game I had to start directing burn at creatures to stay alive. I did get him down to 6 however when the critical turn occurs and he knocks me down to 6. I rip a flame rift off the top I now have a hand of 3 flame rift and 1 fireblast. I have 3 lands in play and at 2 life I win the game.

    flame rift is great, being able to end a game with a fireblast/flame rift combination of cards when the opponent thinks they are stable at 5 to 8 life.

    For the record I onl,y really like to play omne flame rift in a game.

    Also the guy playing 9 land stompy is new to legacy. I like 9 land stompy it was the first legacy deck I put together.

    Anyways moving on: Round 2: Nic Fit

    Game 1: I do 20 damage not much to write home about here.

    In: 2 Sulfuric Vortex Out: 1 Flame rift and 1 Lava spike ( I still don't know how to sideboard this deck) I was trying things out at this point and I didn't see much of his deck other then kitchen Finks game 1 I wasn't sure if he was Rock or Nic fit.

    Game 2: Sulfuric Vortex starts the metronome and I get it swinging faster with extra burn. I win. Seemed easy. This player is always very good and can be difficult to win against.

    Round 3: my Friend playing ANT. or TES. anyways it is Storm. We split. then we play.

    Game 1: He gets me while he was at 2. and me without an instant (with a land untapped

    In 2 Sulfuric Vortex 3 Pyrostatic Pillar Out: 4 Keldon Marauders 1 Lava Spike (this was a mistake Keldon Marauders would have been better to have since he has no creatures unless he plays a empty the warrens

    Game 2: He gets 12 goblins and while I delay things with my goblin guide I come up short. Ohh well at least I split.

    Anyways I will post my deck list again later and I think I want to build a sideboarding play so it is robotic.

  16. #2216

    Re: [DTB] Burn

    Quote Originally Posted by RogueBuild View Post
    I said people would either abandon the current all to the head philosophy (which is to basicly aim for the head and ignore everything else and hope you hit 20 damage before they kill you with creatures or gain life) or abandon the deck as a whole.
    I have already responded to your comment above using the following notes which you might have overlooked:
    • I agree that people should indeed abandon playing "brainless, straight to the head Burn", and should gain more experience on the intricacies of when to pay attention to the board - this might actually be more difficult than one might expect, especially since the nature of Rift Bolt, Chain Lightning, and Fireblast make this a bit more difficult. This is also why I've always liked playing Grim Lavamancer, as this creature improves our options in addressing the board whenever necessary (amidst all the other things that this creature brings to the table).
    • I also agree that we should play to the "strengths of the deck concept" instead of diluting the deck with unnecessary preferences - unfortunately, being able to do this first requires an understanding of these concepts, something that doesn't seem to be too common anymore.

    If you would notice, we both agree that people should abandon the "all to the head philosophy", because it's simply foolish to pretend that the board does not exist.

    To add to that, I would suggest that the individuals who believe that Burn is strictly about "all to the head" should gain more experience with winning (or losing) with the deck to be able to understand its subtle intricacies. I've previously noted that this deck is one that "permits one of the smallest margins of error", and unfortunately, some things are best learned through experience. For additional information, kindly refer to the following comment:

    Quote Originally Posted by RogueBuild View Post
    You responded with "what will happen to this archetype in the future..." as to say the need to reconsider the philosophy of the deck might come about sometime later. And I think we are clearly at a point where due to the speed of non-combo decks we should adjust the game plan now and build with a turns 5, 6 and 7+ in mind. That's why my deck is the way it is.
    From what I gather, you are trying to state the following:
    • "due to the speed of non-combo decks we should adjust the game plan now and build with a turns 5, 6 and 7+ in mind"

    Based on the comments that you've provided so far, a concrete basis for your statements have not been presented, and thus, I am unable to determine whether or not I would agree with you. At the end of the day, though, you are entitled to your opinion, and I will respect that opinion if it works for you.

    I would like to point out the following, though, because these might have become too obvious that we've become unable to appreciate these points:
    • Burn is in the DTB section because of its success against the current meta.
    • Most, if not all, the Burn configurations that been successful in the current meta use the Burn Core, as shown below:
    • NONE of the Burn lists that have had notable success were built similarly to your suggested build. This is not to say that your build isn't okay; this is to simply state this observable fact.
    • Personally, this is the first time that I've seen Burn in the DTB section (given that I've only been browsing through this forum for about 2 years now), and it looks to me like the meta is more ripe than ever for Burn's success (which has already happened).

    I simply wish to present the facts, and it will still be up to you to interpret these details as you see fit, as we are all entitled to our opinion.

    Regards,
    jares

  17. #2217

    Re: [DTB] Burn

    Quote Originally Posted by RogueBuild View Post
    If you where to go back to my build, which was posted about 9 or 10 pages ago I think, you would see I run plenty of things to get me around a Leyline as well as a CotV set to 1, and if I take my time I can get around Counterbalance. And my SB makes it even easier.
    Good for you. Your build surely won't benefit from Flame Rift as well as the Burn Core does from it, so it's really a no-brainer for you to forgo playing it. Your build is indeed better-off playing Flamebreak, by far.

    Cheers,
    jares

  18. #2218

    Re: [DTB] Burn

    Quote Originally Posted by jares View Post
    From what I gather, you are trying to state the following:
    • "due to the speed of non-combo decks we should adjust the game plan now and build with a turns 5, 6 and 7+ in mind"

    Based on the comments that you've provided so far, a concrete basis for your statements have not been presented, and thus, I am unable to determine whether or not I would agree with you. At the end of the day, though, you are entitled to your opinion, and I will respect that opinion if it works for you.
    Ok, some facts to show how the rest of the MTG world has sped up and we have been at the same point since. Fireblast, which is the card that made a turn 3 kill 1st possible has been around since Visions in 1997. A turn 3 win at this point in time was HUGE. Keep in mind, there was no combo yet. No Storm, no Urza's Saga printing Memory Jar or Time Spiral. Yes, Visions did give birth to the 1st true combo deck, Pros/Bloom but that deck had to be build 1st and by small groups of people all over because we didn't have the internet in every home to get everyone around the world to help out. Fireblast was a quick replacement for a deck that had always been around. Since Visions no card has been printed that allows us a faster possible clock, only cards that make that turn 3-4 kill more likely. Tempest, later in 1997, gives us Mogg Fanatic (a mainstay for the deck until the rule change a few years ago). Stronghold and Exodus, both in 1998, give us Shock (only now deemed unworthy since we have Lava Spike and Rift Bolt) and PoP. Flame Rift is printed in 2000, Lava Spike in 2004, and Rift Bolt not until 2006 with Time Spiral. Rift Bolt and Lava Spike being the 2 most important spells in that since since Fireblast as they are the only 2 that make a turn 3 win more likely (note: all of these spells speed up the clock make a turn 4 win more likely). So what you see over the last 15 years is a core deck that, while the card names have changed Shock-> Lava Spike, Incinerate -> Rift Bolt, Mogg Fanatic->
    Hellspark, Keldon or GGuide, a turn 3 win is still the fastest and the average win of turn 4/5 is still much more likely.

    Meanwhile in the world of Aggro decks that used to hope to win by turns 6-9 can now win on turns 4-6 thanks to cards like Goyf, Delver, TombStalker, Dredge/Bridge from Below, Steppe Lynx, and an entire deck worth of goblins, just to name a few. And most of them have only been printed or made useful by other cards being printed in the last 5-6 years. Until the last few years only Combo, Affinity and Goblins had had the kind of kind of explosive kills that Burn has been capable of since 1997.

    And Control? Aside from Stax and the extremely rare and equally annoying Stasis deck played once every few months by the guy no body like at your local tourney, control today has the kind of clock Aggro had 5 or 6 years ago. They plan to win before turn 10. If you haven't been playing for at lest 8 years you don't likely know that even in Legacy things used to be a lot slower.

    Even when Burn still played Shock, Incinerate, and an X-Spell or 2 the likelihood you could race someone was much more in the Burn player's favor then it is now. Sure, our spells have made our damage more consistent, but our overall target of turn 4 is still the same as it has been for 15 years. Meanwhile Combo is faster (which didn't exist 15 years ago), Aggro has cut its expected kill turn almost in half to be neck and neck with us and Control of today is more like Aggro of 8 years ago.

    We are no longer college level sprinters racing 4th graders. They all grew up and got faster and are continuing to do so. Magic is not a game about running a fair race, its a game about taking advantage of over powered/broken cards, cheating massive creatures into play, or playing a game by yourself for 5 mins and then letting the other play know when they died (my basic view of combo). There is NOTHING in burn that is even close to being broken or even overpowered. Many of the cards are even viewed as under powered. The only option for Burn is to trip them.

  19. #2219

    Re: [DTB] Burn

    Quote Originally Posted by RogueBuild View Post
    We are no longer college level sprinters racing 4th graders. They all grew up and got faster and are continuing to do so. Magic is not a game about running a fair race, its a game about taking advantage of over powered/broken cards, cheating massive creatures into play, or playing a game by yourself for 5 mins and then letting the other play know when they died (my basic view of combo). There is NOTHING in burn that is even close to being broken or even overpowered. Many of the cards are even viewed as under powered. The only option for Burn is to trip them.
    That was a very useful history lesson, and assuming that all the details that you've provided is accurate, that also seems to be a very good observation. Having noted all this information, I'm now wondering about how you would you relate all that to the details that I've noted previously; shown below are the said details:
    • Burn is in the DTB section because of its success against the current meta.
    • Most, if not all, the Burn configurations that been successful in the current meta use the Burn Core, as shown below:
    • NONE of the Burn lists that have had notable success were built similarly to your suggested build. This is not to say that your build isn't okay; this is to simply state this observable fact.
    • Personally, this is the first time that I've seen Burn in the DTB section (given that I've only been browsing through this forum for about 2 years now), and it looks to me like the meta is more ripe than ever for Burn's success (which has already happened).

    I'd be interested to hear your interpretation of these facts in relation to the information that you've discussed just now.

    Regards,
    jares

  20. #2220
    Stackbuilder

    Join Date

    Mar 2012
    Posts

    859

    Re: [DTB] Burn

    Quote Originally Posted by RogueBuild View Post
    If you where to go back to my build, which was posted about 9 or 10 pages ago I think, you would see I run plenty of things to get me around a Leyline as well as a CotV set to 1, and if I take my time I can get around Counterbalance. And my SB makes it even easier.
    I don't see as much Chalices as I see Leylines but even if it would be a significant meta factor, there are plenty of options why you don't have to scoop with an ordinary Burn built:


    I'd rather have a faster clock in most matchups than to built a slower deck just to have an advantage in a few. Of course, if your metagame is really that special, your way might be the better choice.

Thread Information

Users Browsing this Thread

There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)