People are missing they key point of the story, true or not.

Playing into an opponent's Chalice in hopes that they will forget the trigger? Clever use of the rules, like it or not. They way they're written you're good to go.

Key point is that the opponent in this instance didn't forget the trigger. They operated the game state 100% as they should and were left in a disadvantageous position because of it. That's it. All this nonsense about to Chalice or not is beyond the heart of the argument.

If you as a player forget zero of your triggers, then zero of your triggers should be missed, regardless of what your opponent does.