Quote Originally Posted by Zilla View Post
I don't think anyone is suggesting that SCG results are irrelevant by any means. They're simply not the end-all be-all barometer for what is and is not viable in the format. Obviously "no innovation echo chamber" is hyperbolic, but there's some truth to it.

The same top level players do well in almost every event, and those players and their friends are choosing to play a particular subset of decks, and so are of course doing well with them.

I suspect that if those same players chose to tune and sleeve up Maverick for a few events, it would start looking to some people like an unstoppable force in the metagame that can only be fixed with a ban, and then we can be having this same discussion about Green Sun's Zenith next month, like Brainstorm this month, and Show and Tell last month, and on and on and on.

Or we can accept that, over time, the Legacy card pool is deep enough to adapt to almost any "dominant" force available to it. If that actually proves to be untrue for more than a few months, then maybe action is necessary.
I guess this opens up a lot of other questions that would derail this thread, but it could lead to interesting discussions that might have already been covered here in other threads and around the net.
Is it all in the player and decks mean nothing? (obviously it lies somewhere in the middle)
Hypothetically a strong enough team would essentially be able to get anything banned, by just showing up with 20 players playing the same thing that is hard to hate out at every event (is this what happened with vengevival?). If the player population at large can't beat/hate out said deck/card in the hands of an excellent player over multiple events isn't that grounds for a banning of some sort? the whole appeal of big tournaments for a lot of people unlike in chess is that you can get there and get lucky against anyone. If that stops happening cause of a specific metagame or strategy it is very bad for business.
I think in general terms maverick is a way easier deck to hate out (if necessary) than anything with blue, just cause of the nature of counterspells.