I struggled with understanding what the debate was about too, but think I get it now.
So let's assume that no rules changes are made to correct what seems like a flaw in the design of this card...

I still don't think it is Legacy playable.
Does it even break Modern? It's difficult to power it out early because almost all fast-mana is banned. Once you have your library in hand, you still need to win on the spot in a way that isn't easily disruptible and with limited mana resources.


Edit: As printed, without any rules changes, my initial reaction is that it is only bannable in EDH. And even then, I'm not certain because stuff like Necropotence exists.