I believe that a few successful Burn builds have already tried to go with a main-decked Sulfuric Vortex, and I would agree that it would be an acceptable alternative to the slot for Keldon Marauders, especially in a meta littered with the aforementioned cards. I guess that the major consideration for such a change would probably be the fact that it's a 3-cc card, but otherwise, it'll likely just fit right in.
Cheers,
jares
I personally think that running just 17 lands causes major concerns, and I have already posted the figures for this configuration. I personally wouldn't go below 19 lands, but at the end of the day, we will all have to make our own choices for the risks that we want to take. Also, note that running fetches lowers the land count even further within the game, which increases the likelihood that keeping a hand with one land would be a bad idea given that you're less likely to get that second land to maintain the tempo.
I hope this helps.
Kind Regards,
jares
Keldon Marauders.. If I was to remove this from my Decklist (Found in my first post on page 104) I'd have 4 slots available. Sulfuric Vortex is an option, But I doubt I want 4. I have also thought about Smash to Smithereens as a 4 of.
Sulfuric Vortex, Of course works with any matchup. Keeps pressure going. but should I really have 4??
Smash to Smithereens doesn't work with a bunch of matchups like Dredge or Reanimator. But tons of decks are using Artifacts these days and being able to kill an artifact game one is kind of nice.
Of course the matchup I really want to improve is Reanimator.
Running [4x] Sulfuric Vortex will definitely be the wrong call because you don't really want it early, and having it in multiples isn't also very favorable. I'd run [3x] at most, but [2x] might be the safest call (then maybe have the 3rd one in the sideboard if necessary).
As for the Reanimator match-up, I'm sorry to say this, but there really ain't much we can do in the main deck to address that without diluting the deck drastically. The best we can do is address that weakness from the sideboard.
Cheers,
jares
Unfortunately Reanimator is our roughest match-up, we have to hope they cannot get Iona out game 1, and then game 2 we HAVE to find graveyard hate. I have dedicated 5 slots to graveyard hate, 4 Faerie Macabre and 1 Tormod's Crypt and I have still had match-ups where I don't draw any hate. This match-up would probably by my strongest reason to splash another color, ideally white for Path to Exile. But splashing another color may drop consistency only to improve the match-up against one deck.
@Neotech
Land was never a problem, a game or two I drew only two lands, but even that really didnt hurt me too bad.
Splashing green was detrimental. The deck runs smoothly and effectively because of its mono colored nature. Out of my five losses, I honestly think I could have won two of them, and at least had a fighting chance with one more had I kept my regular build. I do however enjoy Fetch lands, I do not think they hurt that much. I just hate the continual shuffling and searching.
Reanimator, and Dredge are just hard. Flat out we are not really equipped to tangle with them.
The best bang since the big one!
@jars @ neotech
I run 2 Sulfuric Vortex main, and absolutely love it. It is an all-star. You never want to draw many of them, and it is situational, but no deck wants to see it, and it puts your opponent on tilt. Decks that can handle it game one, it forces the player to occupy more attention on it than they normally wish too. Decks that cannot handle it game one, the players constantly grumble about it.
For me, 2 Sulfuric Vortex will have a permanent spot in my builds, until something better is printed.
The best bang since the big one!
Good to know that Sulfuric Vortex is working very well for you given that it's a 3-cc card and that you're running only 17 lands. I personally like that card's placement in the meta now, and I'll also do some testing with it to see for myself.
Cheers,
jares
It's just funny how things work out. I run three maindeck and never seem to see them. Overall, I think it can be agreed upon 2 minimum no matter what meta is being encountered.
As far as Keldon Marauders is concerned, I'm not sure it would be the first thing to cut from the deck. I know a true burn deck wants as many 3 for 1 spells as it can manage, but burn also prevails through cards like the Marauders and Hellspark Elementals that provide card advantage.
This is how I see it: For 2 mana a minimum of 2 damage is being done, alright not the best...but the 3/3 body has always made some type of impact on the game. If he does get through, 5 damage for 2 mana isn't too shabby by any means especially considering it is only one card (burn use to run incinerates maindeck). If not, chances are it does 2 damage, blocks/attacks and kills an opposing creature or draws some type of removal. The advantage he provides (think when running next to Figures or Lavamancers) lets the deck gel better since it is USUALLY never a dead card. Of course there are always exceptions, but I feel the pros outweigh the cons here.
For Hellspark Elemental, the unearth ability really shines. It can attack with the other critters for trampling damage or appear out of nowhere when your opponent forgets about it. This card has literally won me a game (opponent forgot about my graveyard). Again it is done with only 1 card, which like the marauders, is what makes it fit in with the deck and makes it so playable.
Then again neither one will help you against reanimator or combo...
What I am wondering, can creatureless burn (or just guides and hellspark or whatever) truly survive in a diverse meta without some luck? I know about overextending, but against many decks it almost seems like the correct play.
Never thought that a deck which folds to single random cards like CoP:R or Leyline of Sanctity can advance to a so-called DtB.
Winning a SCG twice doesn't necessarily warrant this status...
e@rdvermampfa
Reanimator folds to an assortment of cards, it is a DtB
also, it has nothing to do with how many tournemants a deck wins. Decks do not win matches people do. And Burn posts solid standings wherever it plays.
also I do not punt to Sanctity or CoP: Red, ever. Decks that run them really cannot stop me from casting Anarchy, so I could care less about either of them.
I punt to Reanimator, and Dredge. I need them to have bad opening hands coupled with drawing into my sideboard.
Burn is a DtB, but if people want to advert back to thinking it is garbage, that is fine to, easier for me and the rest of us who pilot it to win.
The best bang since the big one!
Kindly note that the inclusion of a deck in the DTB section isn't based on one person's whim, as it is based on a formula that quantifies the standards of being included in this section. Anyone may correct me if I am mistaken.
In a manner of speaking, you're correct in saying that winning SCG twice doesn't necessarily warrant the DTB status, because it technically takes more than that.
Also note that Burn does not "fold" to the aforementioned cards. I encourage you to explore this archetype further so that you may have an understanding of your statement.
Having said that, I also never thought that Burn would be in the DTB section, as I always felt that it was Tier 1.5, but not resilient enough to be Tier 1. Good to see that the hard work has paid-off for those that have been trying to develop this archetype.
Cheers,
jares
True words my friend.
Summarizing what we have written in the last pages, I think we can agree on the core of this deck but not on the "filling slots" due to personal preferences and meta choices. So would be a neverending discussion here.
Just main deck:
We all agree on (I hope that I don't make a mistake.):
4 Lightning Bolt
4 Chain Lightning
4 Rift Bolt
4 Lava Spike
4 Goblin Guide
4 Price of Progress
4 Fireblast
So these are 28 cards that has to be played in every burn.dec.
Lets focus on the mana base:
17-20 lands are fine
Lands that can be played are:
Mountain, Barbarian Ring, red fetchlands
Now, here come the "fillers" or cards of not so high quality like Lightning Bolt and co.
So 28 + 17 is 45 and 28 + 20 is 48. So we have still 12 to 15 slots left.
Cards that can be played in this slots are:
Keldon Marauders, Hellspark Elemental, Grim Lavamancer, Shard Volley, Flame Rift,
Sulfuric Vortex, Figure of Destiny, Volcanic Fallout
If I have forgotten a card, I'm sorry.
We cannot argue about the "perfect list" but about which cards are playable and which experiences we have made.
WantToPonder
former: Team SpasticalAction & Team RugStar Berlin
Team MTG Berlin
The Dragonstorm
http://www.mtgthesource.com/forums/s...he-Dragonstorm
I agree with the generalization. Seeing it that way lets me think more about the options I have to fill those slots. I do agree that 19 to 20 lands seems like the better option. I'm even leery of running 19, but I feel that is more my personal preference.
I think I have to try out a few Grim Lavamancers I know that changes the manabase I'd like to run, but it might be the card I'm looking for.
I'm also personally on the side of maximizing the probability of opening with 2 lands, which is why I like running 20 lands. I've been revisiting the configuration running fetch lands, and so far I've been pleased with how it has played out. I'll be posting some results as soon as I have the time. Meanwhile, you might want to try running from 6-8 fetch lands in your testing of Grim Lavamancer (I'm currently testing 7). Take note, though, that you will have to take out Hellspark Elemental if you with to try Grim Lavamancer, as the lack of synergy of these two cards is obvious.
Cheers,
jares
What do you guys thinks of bump in the night ?
A deck list like 28 key spells + 19 lands ( with 11 fetchs + 4 badland + 4 mountain ) + 4 bump +4 needle drop + 2 sulfuric vortex +1 top ( good with fetches and allow not to draw lands, and if we got lots of land we can "draw with top" after tutorising the card we wanted )
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)