[DO NOT TRY TO SELL IN HERE] Pimp Legacy Decks

[WargzII]

Hey, some random stuff i like from french commander 1v1





Last news

[WargzII]

My Marath commander decklist (1v1 banlist)

[WargzII]

Griselbrand decklist (still 1v1)






Sorry for triple post, needed more than 11 pix

[blackberrybold]

Most impressive card for me, the nm Beta Bird, since i cant force myself to pay for a playset of them, but i want it so badly :(

[nedleeds]

Hey, some random stuff i like from french commander 1v1

Wish more of America would embrace the 1v1 EDH format ... it's really fun. We're too social and neckbeardy over here.

[Megadeus]

Wish more of white America would embrace the 1v1 EDH format ... it's really fun. We're too social and neckbeardy over here.

I keep trying to convince my crew to try it because multi-player is depressing. All I want to do is feel like I'm actually trying to achieve something rather than Solitairing until someone plays some off the wall Genesis Wave for 47 or some shit.

[MoxMonkey]

Wish more of white America would embrace the 1v1 EDH format ... it's really fun. We're too social and neckbeardy over here.

Multiplayer EDH is just more fun for some of us :P Only time I play 1v1 is vintage :D

[nedleeds]

I keep trying to convince my crew to try it because multi-player is depressing. All I want to do is feel like I'm actually trying to achieve something rather than Solitairing until someone plays some off the wall Genesis Wave for 47 or some shit.

Do it. Turn Thursday night Wu DH into 1v1 throw down. Everyone pay in for some sweet EDH card as a prize. That isn't foil. And isn't English unless it's beta or Arab. Posting EDH is a solid pain in the ass ... I guess I can post my Maralith.

[Togores]

Here my pimp decks. Old TES new TES the altered silennces and ANT. Please dont look at the 2 WB lands, Im not really proud of them and im sorry for them.


Old TES


Altered Silence


New TES


ANT

[thecrav]

Please dont look at the 2 WB lands, Im not really proud of them and im sorry for them.

I like your attitude.

[guillemnicolau]

Here my pimp decks.

Good looking decks overall, but IMO those cards should be upgraded to pimper versions:
Brainstorms FNM -> Mercadian Masques FOIL
Burning Wishes JP -> Judgement FOIL
Chrome Mox DCI -> Mirrodin FOIL
Flooded Strand DCI -> Onslaught FOIL
City of Brass MM -> Junior Super Series for FOIL, Arabian Nights for regular
Sensei's Divining Top FTV -> Champions of Kamigawa FOIL
Duress M10 -> Arena League Promos or 7th Edition FOIL

Also TS Foil Gemstone Mine looks much better than the promo one.
And by the way, no sideboard?

[Secretly.A.Bee]

Wow, aren't we mister opinion? I like the b. Wishes and the moxen (have a set myself, like them a lot more). I like the direction onslaught fetches as I like fluidity and since they aren't likely to print old border zen fetches, this is awesome. I prefer the mm CoB, then 8th, then 7th, then AN, and the rest is junk. Duresses are whatever. I don't like any of the art and as a common, who cares? The only people who really care are the ones with 7th ed and that's only because of obvious reasons. Brainstorms are also whatever, mine are Japanese IA Colds nap precons, idk why, I just really like the picture and they spoke to me. The tops are annoying but it doesn't mean that they aren't pimp. Mine are Japanese non-foil and two more English I altered which I also enjoy. Just because you dislike a version doesn't make them "not pimp" or "less pimp" even. Overly critical much?

Sent from my SM-N900V using Tapatalk

[phazonmutant]

Wow, aren't we mister opinion? I like the b. Wishes and the moxen (have a set myself, like them a lot more). I like the direction onslaught fetches as I like fluidity and since they aren't likely to print old border zen fetches, this is awesome. I prefer the mm CoB, then 8th, then 7th, then AN, and the rest is junk. Duresses are whatever. I don't like any of the art and as a common, who cares? The only people who really care are the ones with 7th ed and that's only because of obvious reasons. Brainstorms are also whatever, mine are Japanese IA Colds nap precons, idk why, I just really like the picture and they spoke to me. The tops are annoying but it doesn't mean that they aren't pimp. Mine are Japanese non-foil and two more English I altered which I also enjoy. Just because you dislike a version doesn't make them "not pimp" or "less pimp" even. Overly critical much?

Sent from my SM-N900V using Tapatalk

Yeah, maybe he's overly critical, but still. Storm is like the iconic old-border deck - all spells, no stupid creatures. Hell, half the cards' effects aren't even in the same color anymore! It just seems wrong to try to new-border "pimp" it.

[guillemnicolau]

Wow, aren't we mister opinion?Just because you dislike a version doesn't make them "not pimp" or "less pimp" even. Overly critical much?

Most "pimp" is not subjective. What people like is subjective. There is a level of "pimp" that is/can be agreed on by majority of players.

Here is a guide that I think a lot of people can agree with.

Basics (in level of prestige):
Summer > Guru > Arabian Nights Mountains > Foil Unhinged > Beta > Apac/Euro/etc. > FBB > MPR > Foil Zendikar > etc.

Duals:
Summer (mostly unattainable but here as a placeholder) > Beta > Alpha > FBB > Unlimited > Revised

Fetchlands:
Original Onslaught Foil > Zendikar Foil > Original Onslaught > Original Zendikar > Judge Foil

All other cards:
Beta/Alpha (if available) > Original art black border (ie: Kird Ape) / Foreign version (korean, etc) > Original Foil (STP/Wasteland) All languages > Original non foil black border (Karakas, Dreadnought, Show & Tell) > Judge foil > FTV foil> White border

What I wanted to say was that there are much better versions of those cards if we are talking about serious pimping (and not just "don't criticize my cards because I like them!")

[Secretly.A.Bee]

Well the edit was a nice touch. This isn't just about "most pimp." Recently an all german/russian nonfoil list was posted and was received warmly. And then this reception. Neither are "most pimped" but one received several positive feedback statements and the other got junked and picked apart immediately. Just looking for a little forgiveness. This thread would get a post a week tops if we had to live up to the standards you just subjected the last deck to. Just saying.

Sent from my SM-N900V using Tapatalk

[guillemnicolau]

I understand what you are saying, and it's true, that's why I said that those are good looking decks overall.
About the german/russian nonfoil list, I think that for people who doesn't like foil but like rare languages, it was really pimp, as those cards are not easy to find, and there was consistency in the deck (all the available russian cards, and the rest in german).

[CabalTherapy]

Would you guys consider a totally fucked up burn deck as pimped? I mean: ugliest white board mountains, random Bolts and all cards not better than in "good" condition. I guess I goes into another direction but I think such a deck could also have "style". (List should be nonethless solid and not casual)

[Bed Decks Palyer]

Would you guys consider a totally fucked up burn deck as pimped? I mean: ugliest white board mountains, random Bolts and all cards not better than in "good" condition. I guess I goes into another direction but I think such a deck could also have "style". (List should be nonethless solid and not casual)

It was posted here not long ago... I mean about few hundred pages back. I consider Fat Kid's Sligh a very pimp deck, with only "buried for a month in my backyard" Dredge to be a bit better.

[Togores]

Good looking decks overall, but IMO those cards should be upgraded to pimper versions:
Brainstorms FNM -> Mercadian Masques FOIL
I like this brainstorms cause was the 1st foil I got. I have on MM foil in my vintage deck. (this could be upgraded but are the 4 cards I have played more in my live)
Burning Wishes JP -> Judgement FOIL
I like this cause it remebers me to the gerudos of Zelda game, I also wanna alter this playset so it looks like twinrova wins.
Chrome Mox DCI -> Mirrodin FOIL
I dont like the other, dosnt look like a medalion, its like a mercure ball. This versión looks more like an real mox.
Flooded Strand DCI -> Onslaught FOIL
Thats true, But I had this. Now I wanna change the onslaught deltas for dci and cash because so all my fetches will be in same border.
City of Brass MM -> Junior Super Series for FOIL, Arabian Nights for regular
I like this because so all rainbow lands have same border. Could be 8th edition but its almost the same.
Sensei's Divining Top FTV -> Champions of Kamigawa FOIL
I got them cheap, this should be upgraded that true. But kamigawa sensei are not cheap at all right now.
Duress M10 -> Arena League Promos or 7th Edition FOIL
I like this cause it remember me in his manner to hellraiser.

Also TS Foil Gemstone Mine looks much better than the promo one.
And by the way, no sideboard?
Side borard is not pimp right now. Its on the way, I have the chain of vapors foil but I have not xantids, carpets, massacres, dread of night, decay (62€ for a foil english right now LOL). So I prefered not to show.

I think the pimp depends on what you like. OBV If I wanted to make the most pimp it would be all foil japanese. But prices are too hight.
MY ruling are:
Foil japanese
Foil english
japanese
German (duals and cards of like 4th edition that are not on the above)
rest...

[JPoJohnson]

It was posted here not long ago... I mean about few hundred pages back. I consider Fat Kid's Sligh a very pimp deck, with only "buried for a month in my backyard" Dredge to be a bit better.

Do you have picture of either of those? Those would be awesome to see!