All B/R update speculation.

[Ace/Homebrew]

I have a warning on my account for shit that happened in here.

Is that something you get to see with your mod powers?? Is there a way to view how many warnings you have or how many posts you've had deleted? Do you guys talk about me when I'm not logged in?

On topic: all formats are fine, no bannings. Some unbannings might be nice!

[Barook]

Is that something you get to see with your mod powers?? Is there a way to view how many warnings you have or how many posts you've had deleted? Do you guys talk about me when I'm not logged in?

On topic: all formats are fine, no bannings. Some unbannings might be nice!

I'd be very suprised if Bloom Titan doesn't get banhammered in Modern.

[Dice_Box]

Is that something you get to see with your mod powers?? Is there a way to view how many warnings you have or how many posts you've had deleted? Do you guys talk about me when I'm not logged in?

On topic: all formats are fine, no bannings. Some unbannings might be nice!

It's in your profile under Infractions. You should be able to see it. I just checked your account anyway and you don't have any. Trust me, you would know if you did. We send messages to those that earn them.

[JPoJohnson]

I have my fingers crossed that Frantic Search is coming off the list. Each time it's come up in conversation in this thread, it never has a solid argument against it.

[Bobmans]

It's a irrisorius card, if u want to play Grisel or Emrakul, play it but with a Sneak Attack or Through the breach, S&T is an absurd card that would never be printed and has CMC 3, ridiculous.

Still, you have not answered the question.

Ey guys! relax! Sorry for be new on this forum and spent the most part of my time reading against posting, but hey! It's an awesome way to say "welcome" to new people, keep doing it you'll be fine.

If you poke the wasps nest....

[Secretly.A.Bee]

I have my fingers crossed that Frantic Search is coming off the list. Each time it's come up in conversation in this thread, it never has a solid argument against it.

Don't tease me. Seriously, if I could play 4 Frantic Search in 4c Reanimator, I wouldn't be able to change tables from round to round due to the embarrassment my raging boner would cause me.

Sent from my SM-N920V using Tapatalk

[Lemnear]

It's in your profile under Infractions. You should be able to see it. I just checked your account anyway and you don't have any. Trust me, you would know if you did. We send messages to those that earn them.

#offtopic
Really? I never saw an "infraction" note iny profile and this thread paired with Seans postings here should have handed me a few :)

[death]

#FranticSearch

All I really want is *Reset on your EOT, kill you..*

[Dice_Box]

It's a separate tab. I could see it before I became a mod.

[Darkenslight]

#FranticSearch

All I really want is *Reset on your EOT, kill you..*

Nah, I want to see the reutrn of, "EOTFOFYL".

[Mr Miagi]

Oh Frantic search, I long for you, but you're still on banned list

This card would be so cool in legacy. It might actually make a Solidarity a tier 1,5 deck (again). But let's be honest this would promote another blue combo deck, that would take quite long to durdle arround before winning. My guess is we are not allowed to have this fun

Unban of Memory jar would be also fine by me, but I also doubt we gonna see that

so as per usual for legacy .. no changes

[Lemnear]

Legacy - No Changes
Modern - random-Amulet-Bloom-part banned
Vintage - Dark Petition restricted

[supremePINEAPPLE]

Dark petition is a weird one. It seems like it's made workshops firmly the best deck again with TPS right behind it. I feel like the format is even more play-draw dependent than before which isn't a good development even though I love TPS.

[tescrin]

You got the standard welcome for this thread. Mostly because it always ends up so combative. (I have a warning on my account for shit that happened in here.)

Same here :D. My only regret is not screen-shotting the deleted posts. For posterity of course.

@Shrek
I think anyone newer to Legacy hates S&T. I found it to be the most obnoxious deck when I started because regardless of my interaction, I couldn't figure it out. Now I blind Therapys pretty well on them and have a robust plan. It's just an annoying angle of attack. That all said, T1 Emrakuls are still pretty obnoxious.. but it's not much different than 14 goblins. Sometimes combo just has it. Similarly, sometimes you open with something like
T1 DRS, T2 Thalia, Wasteland; I'm sure that's just as obnoxious for combo. Or you open with Delver, Daze, Force, Thoughtseize Wasteland.

Whatever type of player you are, if your deck is any good, it has brutal T1 or T2 openings. Except D&T. Who knows how that thing works. It's like the anti-matter of Legacy. It works; but we've yet to explain it :p


Again, I'm seriously on the "don't mess stuff up wizards" train.

[Ace/Homebrew]

Dark petition is a weird one. It seems like it's made workshops firmly the best deck again with TPS right behind it. I feel like the format is even more play-draw dependent than before which isn't a good development even though I love TPS.

Can you (or someone) explain this statement? I do not play Vintage. Is it that Petition made Storm better and MUD has a great Storm matchup?

[supremePINEAPPLE]

Exactly. TPS specifically got better versus blue decks with the extra bombs that need to be countered and is less vulnerable to things like mental misstep than it used to be. It's still miserable to play against shops with the deck though. Stupid shops players and their uncanny ability to win the play.

That said it's not horrible right now and I see plenty of different decks online. Burning tendrils is fun right now since people are trying to use leylines instead of grafdiggers cages as graveyard hate that works well against petition so I've been beating down with griselbrand a lot more instead of trying to tendrils them.

[Blastoderm]

Legacy - No Changes
Modern - random-Amulet-Bloom-part banned
Vintage - Dark Petition restricted

Having Amulet or Bloom on a banlist in any format is pretty embarrassing for that format.

[iatee]

Summer Bloom is a de facto ritual and two rituals and Chrome Mox are already banned in Modern. Fast mana is fast mana. Good-rituals are too good for modern, Moxen and Sol Ring are too good for Legacy.

[Blastoderm]

Summer Bloom is a de facto ritual and two rituals and Chrome Mox are already banned in Modern. Fast mana is fast mana. Good-rituals are too good for modern, Moxen and Sol Ring are too good for Legacy.

You mean bad-rituals are too good for modern?

[rufus]

Having Amulet or Bloom on a banlist in any format is pretty embarrassing for that format.

Are you planning to make the same claim about Fastbond too? I know Fastbond is a lot stronger, but 'play extra lands' can be a powerful effect.